An Bord Pleanála

Disposed cases. Week ended: 25th April 2003. Total cases: 58

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Board Ref. 01 131084 Planning Appeal
Development Permission consequent on 99/863 for house, garage, septic tank or proprietary effluent treatment system, percolation area and
ancillary sevices. Ballintrane, Fenagh, Co. Carlow.
Category
Planning Authority Carlow County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/695
Applicant P.J. and Ornat McHale, Lodged
Decided
13-03-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Dismissed Sec.14 Vexatious/without substance EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 LV2089 Leave to Appeal S37(6)
Development Retain haybarn as a cattle housing unit and extension there to, retain loose shed and ancillary slurry storage.
Claremount, Broadford, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. P02/2191
Applicant Charle Mulqueen, Lodged
Decided
04-04-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Application for leave to appeal refused EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 130798 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of a ruined dwelling and construction of a house and garage.
Upper Skeheen, Mitchelstown, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. N/02/0531
Applicant Jim O'Keeffe Lodged
Decided
25-10-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 130804 Planning Appeal
Development 50 berth marina, clubhouse, chandlery, storage, parking and associated site works.
Keelbeg Pier, Ballincolla, Union Hall, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. W/01/3175
Applicant Gerard O'Mahoney Lodged
Decided
30-10-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 130814 Planning Appeal
Development 25 metre high telecommunications lattice structure with antennae, associated equipment container and palisade fence.
Maulanimirish, Dunmanway, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. W/02/0102
Applicant Meteor Mobile Communications Ltd. Lodged
Decided
31-10-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 201270 Planning Appeal
Development 2 dwellinghouses. Castlefreke Island, Clonakilty, County Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. W/02/4200
Applicant Sean and Padraig O'Regan Lodged
Decided
10-12-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 202613 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to house and conservatory to the rear of house. 37 Alden Grove, Douglas, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. S/03/0290
Applicant Finbarr and Mary Fitzharris Lodged
Decided
22-04-2003
22-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 05B202599 Planning Appeal
Development Removal of dwelling and erect 2 storey dwelling house with septic tank and percolation area.
Cashelgolan, Portnoo, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/2095
Applicant Harry Mc Hugh Lodged
Decided
22-04-2003
24-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 05C201389 Planning Appeal
Development Dwellinghouse and septic tank. Cabra Brook, Churchill, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/7717
Applicant John McGlynn Lodged
Decided
19-12-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 06D201063 Planning Appeal
Development House, entrance, demolition of garage. 34 Woodlawn Park, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02A/0888
Applicant Brendan and Siobhan Maguire Lodged
Decided
18-11-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D201283 Planning Appeal
Development 19 apartments, retention & alteration of 'New Park' including demolition of outbuildings, 34 car spaces, 2 pedestrian entrances.
New Park, Whites Cross, Dublin 18.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02A/0960
Applicant Astondale Construction Limited, Lodged
Decided
11-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D201311 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish single storey playroom/study, utility room, boiler house & erect 2-storey extension with single storey bay window & lean-to
veranda. 19 Newpark Road, Newtownpark Avenue, Blackrock, Co.Dublin
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02B/0760
Applicant Gerard Earley Lodged
Decided
13-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D201313 Planning Appeal
Development 50 metre long and 8 metre high steel post and wire mesh fence adjoining the ninth front tee.
Old Conna Golf Club, Ferndale Road, Rathmichael, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02A/0979
Applicant Old Conna Golf Club Lodged
Decided
16-12-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D201314 Planning Appeal
Development Modifications to existing permission (D00A/0401) to provide changeof use from retail to sale of hot food for consumption off the
premises. Unit 6, Magic Carpet Centre, Cornelscourt, Dublin 18.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02A/0974
Applicant Patrick and John Cronan Lodged
Decided
16-12-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 06D201740 Planning Appeal
Development Alter approved development (Reg.Ref:D98A/0910) to change 2 retail units to betting office, provide ATM, reconfigure 4 apartments.
Site adjoining no. 1 Rochestown Avenue, Dun Laoghaire, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02A/1064
Applicant Nordica Limited Lodged
Decided
23-01-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Application W/D S.140(1)(a) EIS No
View the Report
Board Ref. 06D202490 Planning Appeal
Development Boarding accommodation for 104 pupils, living accommodation for 2 housemasters & 2 tutors. 4 Prep-rooms, 2 day-pupil rooms. Demolish
stores. St. Columbas College, Whitechurch, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16.
Category Protected structure
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire/Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D02A/1129
Applicant The Warden and Fellows of St. Columbas Lodged
Decided
08-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Appeal withdrawn s.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 06F201345 Planning Appeal
Development House, biocycle treatment unit and construction of new biocycle treatment unit to replace existing septic tank.
Bolton, Danesford Avenue, Carrickbrack Road, Bailey, Howth Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. FO2A/1256
Applicant Brian Tucker Lodged
Decided
17-12-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F201542 Planning Appeal
Development Two-storey extension. Rear of 62 St. Peters Terrace, Howth, Dublin 13.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council Reg. Ref. F02B/0631
Applicant Stephen and Janette Lantry Lodged
Decided
08-01-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S202633 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of integrated development of private/Affordable/ Social/Voluntary housing comprising 85 no. mix type units,
courtyard and pedestrian street, underground car park and
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD02A/0465
Applicant T. Quinn Properties Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 06S202676 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of integrated development of private/Affordable/ Social/Voluntary housing comprising 85 no.Mix type units,
courtyard and pededtrian street, underground car park, associated
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD02A/0465
Applicant T. Quinn Properties Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 06S202677 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of integrated development of private/Affordable/ Social/Voluntary housing comprising 85 no. mix type units,
courtyard and pedestrian street, underground car park, associated
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD02A/0465
Applicant T.Quinn Properties Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 06S202678 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of integrated development of Private/Affordable/ Social/Voluntary housing comprising 85 no. mix type units,
courtyard and pedestrian street, underground car park, associated
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD02A/0465
Applicant T. Quinn Properties Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 06S202679 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of integrated development of Private/Affordable/ Social/Voluntary housing comprising 85 no. mix type units,
courtyard and pedestrian street, underground car park, associated
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD02A/0465
Applicant T.Quinn Properties Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 07 130886 Planning Appeal
Development Two houses and associated site services. Bohoona West, Spiddal, Co.Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 01/4164
Applicant Seamus Ó Ceidigh, Lodged
Decided
22-11-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 202603 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of 1 metre wide gable window facing commonage. Loughanbeg, Inverin. Co.Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/284
Applicant Anne Flaherty Lodged
Decided
23-04-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 09 201291 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of bungalow and detached garage with bio-disc sewerage treatment system.
Newtown, Eadestown, Naas, Co.Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/1771
Applicant Joanne Curtin, Lodged
Decided
09-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 201294 Planning Appeal
Development Development of 128 two bedroom apartment in mixed two and three storey buildings on former Presentation Covent grounds adjacent to
Nagle Court. Dillon`s Row, Maynooth, Co.Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 1772/02
Applicant Glenmoy Developmetns Ltd Lodged
Decided
10-12-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 201630 Planning Appeal
Development Reinstatement of destroyed cottage and replacement of existing concrete model septic tank with puraflo model.
Bonynge Bridge, Robertstown, Naas, Co.Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/2041
Applicant Patrick McGann Lodged
Decided
13-01-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 10 201483 Planning Appeal
Development House, biocycle treatment plant and new entrance. Garnagully, Finnan, Ballyragget, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/1479
Applicant Eugene Tallis Lodged
Decided
19-12-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 202630 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition os existing house and outbulidings and provision of overflow carpark of 34 spaces.
St. Nessan's Road, Dooradoyle, Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/144
Applicant Anne Greene Properties, Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 15 130271 Planning Appeal
Development 20 semi-detached houses and one detached house. Dromiskin, Dundalk, Co.Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 99/1416
Applicant Jim Lawlor Lodged
Decided
05-07-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 200899 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing premises,change of use of 1st floor level to 2 apartments, 2 storey extension to rear premises & extension to
existing licensed premises. Upper Main St, Dunleer, Co.Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 02782
Applicant Hazelash Associates Lodged
Decided
21-10-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 201296 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of private enclosed grey hound track / run with fencing and gates.
Bellurgan, Dundalk, Co.Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/1062
Applicant Thomas Keenan Lodged
Decided
12-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 15 WW0286 Water Pollution Licence - Waters
Development Licence to discharge trade/sewage effluent to waters. Gallstown Quarry, Grangebellew, Drogheda, Co.Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 30-1
Applicant Kilsaran Concrete Limited Lodged
Decided
30-08-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Allow appeal amend conditions (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 202641 Planning Appeal
Development 3 houses. Newtown, Carlanstown, Kells, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. KA/30438
Applicant Patrick Gargan Lodged
Decided
24-04-2003
24-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 17 202642 Planning Appeal
Development Retain dormer window on front elevation, window on east elevation,two windows delated on west elevation, revised site layout.
Rathmore, Athboy Road, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. KA/20378
Applicant Jonathan Higgins, Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 20 130754 Planning Appeal
Development Construct 30m high communications tower with microlink dishes, GSMtype antennas and ancillary equipment.
Ballyduffy Townland (Sliabh Ban), Lanesboro, Co.Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 00/1335
Applicant Irish Multichannel, Lodged
Decided
10-10-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 202258 Planning Appeal
Development 1 no. wind turbine, site entrance and access road. Seltannaveeny, Arigna, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/1374
Applicant John & Kevin McLaughlin Lodged
Decided
12-03-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Appeal withdrawn s.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 22 130812 Planning Appeal
Development Retain change to industrial shed/unit/fuel store by extension of one bay to existing shed, retain office, associted site works.
Monakeeba, Thurles, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council Reg. Ref. PLC/24248
Applicant Kevin Ryan Lodged
Decided
29-10-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Application withdrawn EIS No
Board Ref. 22 201362 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use of existing agricultural shed to commercial garage. Maghereagh, Bouladuff, Thurles, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council Reg. Ref. 02/51/0280
Applicant Paul Dempsey Lodged
Decided
19-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 23 129806 Planning Appeal
Development Dwelling house, garage, septic tank system, use of existing entrance and private road.
Clashganny West, Newcastle, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority South Tipperary County Council Reg. Ref. 01/1274
Applicant Desmond O'Keeffe Lodged
Decided
15-05-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 23 202684 Planning Appeal
Development Proprietary waste treatment system and irrigation area. Ballybeg, Newcastle, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority South Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/1225
Applicant Lila Condon Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 25 202639 Planning Appeal
Development House, septic tank, percolation area. Portnashangan, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/5045
Applicant Jacqueline Ann Boniface Lodged
Decided
23-04-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 25A202643 Planning Appeal
Development 9 houses, demolish dereliot building. Blyry Lower, Athlone, Co. Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/1022
Applicant Aiden Kelly Construction Lodged
Decided
25-04-2003
25-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 26 201277 Planning Appeal
Development Construct 2 no. dormer bungalows, treatment units, service road, and ancillary site works.
Lake Big, Rosslare, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/2865
Applicant Peadar Bent Lodged
Decided
10-12-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 202600 Planning Appeal
Development House and domestic garage/store. Fardystown, Killinick, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/3660
Applicant Patrick & Joan Frayne Lodged
Decided
23-04-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 27 202622 Planning Appeal
Development House and retention of mobile home for duration of building. Countybrook, Ballyman Road, enniskerry, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/8072
Applicant Rachael Lumsden, Lodged
Decided
23-04-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 28 201349 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing dwelling house and construct dormer type dwelling house.
Ard-Na-Greine, Coolgarten, Glasheen, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. TP02/26474
Applicant Brian Creedon, Lodged
Decided
18-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N201284 Planning Appeal
Development 2 Storey extension to the side of existing dwelling and porch to front of house.
389 Howth Road, Dublin 5.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 3176/02
Applicant Tom Feeney Lodged
Decided
11-12-2002
24-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N201627 Planning Appeal
Development Two-storey detached house at side and driveway to existing house. 14 Clanawley Road, Killester, Dublin 5.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 3563/02
Applicant E Barrett, Lodged
Decided
15-01-2003
24-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S201273 Planning Appeal
Development Signage featuring back lighting. Grafton Recruitment, 1 Wellington Quay, Dublin 2.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 3256/02
Applicant Grafton Recruitment Lodged
Decided
10-12-2002
23-04-2003
Decision 1st Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29SRL2020 Referral
Development Change of use from motor/warehouse showrooms to a shop for the sale of tiles.
Units 1 & 1C Concord Industrial Estate, Naas Road, Dublin 12.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 2169/02
Applicant I.B.I Property Nominees Limited Lodged
Decided
19-09-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Is development and is exempted development EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 30 CH2078 C.A. Housing Act
Development Mary Street/ Sir Harry's Mall Area Compulsory Purchase Order 2003
Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Limerick City Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Lodged
Decided
06-03-2003
23-04-2003
Decision No objections Received EIS No
Board Ref. 39 201451 Planning Appeal
Development First floor extension and alterations to existing single storey. Norwood Nursing Home, Sidmonton Road, Bray, Co.Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Bray Town Coucil Reg. Ref. 02/128
Applicant Liz and Pat Behan Lodged
Decided
23-12-2002
25-04-2003
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 44 202692 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to a Club house. Callanan's Lane, Carrick-on-suir, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Carrick-on-suir Town Council, Reg. Ref. 13/2003
Applicant Frank Fahy Lodged
Decided
24-04-2003
24-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 50 201375 Planning Appeal
Development House, Emmet Lane, Off O'Rahilly Street, Clonakilty, Co.Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Clonakilty Town Council Reg. Ref. 25/02
Applicant P.J. McCarthy Lodged
Decided
19-12-2002
23-04-2003
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 61 202635 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations to previously approved 863/99. Alterations to existingdwellinghouse and use permitted extension for 2no. self contained
units. 56 Henry Street, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 1081/02
Applicant Thomas Hopkins, Lodged
Decided
23-04-2003
23-04-2003
Decision Invalid- late s.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 65 202612 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use to form betting office, retail unit, residential unit, new shopfronts, satellite dish and external signage.
1 Market Street (Barry's), Kinsale, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Kinsale Town Council Reg. Ref. 33/02
Applicant Ladbrokes Ireland Ltd. Lodged
Decided
22-04-2003
22-04-2003
Decision Invalid- no acknowl.s.127(1)e EIS No

End of Report. 58 Case(s)

30-Apr-2003 15:48

Last modified: 2007-03-22

Weekly lists
Planning Appeals
Other cases

All Planning Cases