An Bord Pleanála

Disposed cases. Week ended: 11th March 2005. Total cases: 102

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Board Ref. 01 209409 Planning Appeal
Development House with garage, mechanical aeration unit, and associated works.

Haroldstown, Tullow, Co. Carlow.
Category
Planning Authority Carlow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/219
Applicant Tracy Cahill Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 01 209527 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of alterations to restaurant and change of use to part bar and function room.

Ballyvergal, Carlow.
Category
Planning Authority Carlow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/280
Applicant Tommy Tougher, Lodged
Decided
01-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 01 209846 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use to composting facility.

Mount View Grange, Tullow, Co. Carlow.
Category
Planning Authority Carlow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/445
Applicant Ray Bolger, Lodged
Decided
25-11-2004
08-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
View the Report
Board Ref. 02 209336 Planning Appeal
Development 1 house.

Drumloman, Kilnaleck, Co. Cavan.
Category
Planning Authority Cavan County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1361
Applicant Mairead Harten Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 211218 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Liscullane, O'Callaghan's Mills, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04-2196
Applicant Lodged
Decided
10-03-2005
10-03-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 04 207377 Planning Appeal
Development Extension of limestone quarry.

Killanully, Ballygarvan, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 02/5680
Applicant John A. Wood Ltd. and Others Lodged
Decided
31-05-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 209393 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Turnaspidogy, Inchigeelagh, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/5984
Applicant T. O'Riordan Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 209395 Planning Appeal
Development Prefabricated multi-purpose room.

Ballinora National School, Waterfall, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/4590
Applicant Board of Management, Ballinora National School. Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 209408 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish house and construct house.

Maulatanvally, Reenascrena, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2121
Applicant Brendan Coakley Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 209453 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of elevational changes and sun room extension to house.

Rockmills, Ballynahallisk, Kildorrery, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6115
Applicant Alan O'Sullivan Lodged
Decided
29-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 211184 Planning Appeal
Development House, domestic garage, treatment unit and irrigation area.

Dunmanus East, Goleen, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/7002
Applicant John Hellen Lodged
Decided
08-03-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 05B209355 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use and retention and completion of works to store and charity shop to house retail shop, deli, off-licence, restaurant,
store and staff accommodation.
Harbour, Dunfanaghy, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3230
Applicant Daniel and Ann Sweeney Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05B210839 Planning Appeal
Development Dha teach conaithe le dha dhabhach searachais ar leigh agus dha gharaiste ar leith a thogail.

Dhoire Beaga, Gaoth Dobhair, Chontae Dhun na nGall.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2824
Applicant Padraig MacGiolla Easboig Lodged
Decided
16-02-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 05C209424 Planning Appeal
Development House and septic tank.

Rathdonnell, Trentagh, Co.Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/7866
Applicant Tony Langan Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with same conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05D209360 Planning Appeal
Development House, with septic tank and garage.

Camblestown, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6439
Applicant John Flavin Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05D209361 Planning Appeal
Development 2 no. houses with waste water treatment systems, access road and ancillary works.

Castlewray, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6357
Applicant Kevin Kelly Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05D209789 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to rear and side of school, new septic tank and new vehicular entrance.
Cashelshanaghan National School, Cashelshanaghan, Letterkenny,
Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6383
Applicant Board of Management Cashelshanaghan National School Lodged
Decided
26-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209380 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish workshop and erect dwelling.

89 Johnstown Avenue, Cabinteely, Dublin 18.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0732
Applicant Brendan Kelly Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209382 Planning Appeal
Development Construct c.2884 sq. m. two storey over basement leisure and fitness centre and associated site works (previously approved
D02A/0558).
Brookfield, Carrickmines Great and Jamestown, Dublin 18.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0877
Applicant Park Developments (Dublin) Ltd., Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with same conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209383 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish single storey extension to front, side and rear and construct new single and two storey replacement extension.

Forest View, Bishop's Lane, Kilternan, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04B/0619
Applicant Martin and Michelle O'Keefe Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209388 Planning Appeal
Development Construct two storey over-semi basement two bedroom house and all associated site works.

Oakwood, Tivoli Road, Dun Laoghaire, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0712
Applicant Kathy Stapleton Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209390 Planning Appeal
Development Two storey villa style detached house at rear with entrance with two car spaces.

77 Churchtown Road Lower, Churchtown, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0564
Applicant Kay McGuinness Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
08-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209446 Planning Appeal
Development Amendment to residential development (previously approved D03A/0477) comprising of 12 no. balconies to each apartment block
J, K, L & M. Former Sheraton Caravan Park Site, Dublin Road,
Shankill, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0880
Applicant Walter Browne Tudor Homes Ltd., Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209448 Planning Appeal
Development Construct single storey extension to side and rear of hosue, reduce size of existing window and provide rooflights to first
and ground floor.
82 Westbury, Stillorgan, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04B/0630
Applicant Eugene and Rose Lalor Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D209449 Planning Appeal
Development Two storey house with attic space with roof windows, at side to front and rear.

16 Sycamore Drive, The Park, Cabinteely, Dublin 18.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0910
Applicant Alex Vaughan, Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06DRL2199 Referral
Development Whether the partial demolition of a dwellinghouse and constructionof a large single storey extension is or is not development and
is or is not exempted development
30 Deans Grange Cottages, Deans Grange Road, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. 30/04
Applicant Anthony Callinan Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Is development and is not exempted development EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F211233 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations to units 34 and 35 to provide one unit, change of use from industrial to showroom.
Units 34 and 35,
North Park Business Park, North Road, Finglas, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. F04A/1738
Applicant D Hanratty, G. Dwyer and Peter Brady of ECI Lighting Ltd. Lodged
Decided
09-03-2005
09-03-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 06S208983 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing stairwell and toilet block, alter and refurbish existing building, four-storey exension to rear comprising offices
plant room, staff and public area, ancillary works to Credit Union
building (protected structure). 3 The Mall, Lucan, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0210
Applicant Lucan District Credit Union, Lodged
Decided
24-09-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S209377 Planning Appeal
Development 11 apartments in 1 building ranging from 3 to 4 storeys in height.The proposed building is to provide for 11 two bedroom units with
balconies, communal back garden and shared roof terrace.
Site North of Oldcourt Road, Ballycullen, Dublin 24.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0579
Applicant Ellier Developments Limited, Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S209420 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing house and construct 31 no. mix type houses and 6 no. apartments along with 71 no. car parking spaces, relocation
of site entrance and site works.
Heathersett, Old Court Road, Tallaght, Dublin 24.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0594
Applicant Tony and Marian Haugh, Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S209428 Planning Appeal
Development Convert existing attic space to playroom/storage which will incorporate the construction of a new flat roof dormer window to
the rear of the existing house.
5 Rochfort Way, Rochfort Downs, Lucan, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04B/0426
Applicant Paul McCarthy, Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with same conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S209478 Planning Appeal
Development Two storey house, new vehicular entrance and associated site works in side garden.

61 Whitecliff Estate, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0623
Applicant Kevin Pepper Lodged
Decided
02-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S211116 Planning Appeal
Development Pitched roof to the front over the existing dormer window and ground floor window, conversion of rear roof space and garage,
extension to rear.
10 Anne Devlin Park, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04B/0681
Applicant Peter J. Healy Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 06SRL2200 Referral
Development Whether the use of lands for the purpose of agriculture and development (including the laying out of metalled surface and
storage of container) is or is not development or is or is not
exempted development. Hilltop, Athgoe, Newcastle, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. ED04/0011
Applicant Patrick Moran, Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Split decision (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 131491 Planning Appeal
Development House with associated services.

Carrownavohanaun, Gort, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/4582
Applicant John Monaghan Lodged
Decided
10-01-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 209419 Planning Appeal
Development 22 no. semi-detached houses, 4 no. detached houses with garages, reduced sites for houses 9-14, new waste treatment plant with
decommissioning of old,increase in site boundary.
Pollaturk, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2286
Applicant Thomas Costello Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 07 209430 Planning Appeal
Development C.O.U. of ground and first floors to licenced premises, 2nd floor to storage, rear extension for use as licensed premises.

Bridge Street, Athenry, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3219
Applicant Daragh Raftery Lodged
Decided
29-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 209507 Planning Appeal
Development House containing carer's apartment, sewage treatment system and percolation area.

Letterfrack, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3208
Applicant Pauline Flynn Lodged
Decided
01-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 210987 Planning Appeal
Development Two-storey apartment block consisting of 4 no. apartments with associated car parking and site development works.

Frenchpark, Oranbeg Townland, Oranmore, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/5111
Applicant Barry Fitzgerald Lodged
Decided
23-02-2005
09-03-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 08 208703 Planning Appeal
Development Construct a dwellinghouse with wastewater treatment unit and percolation area.

Callinafercy, Milltown, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 2357/04
Applicant Pauline Houlihan, Lodged
Decided
01-09-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 LV2358 Leave to Appeal S37(6)
Development Construct agricultural machinery/commercial building with all ancillary site works.

Knockreagh, Killarney Rd., Milltown, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1488
Applicant Lodged
Decided
11-02-2005
10-03-2005
Decision Application for leave to appeal granted EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 207390 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of 160 dwellings and all associated works.

Capdoo Commons, Clane, Co. Kildare
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/2064
Applicant Westar Investments Limited Lodged
Decided
31-05-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 208205 Planning Appeal
Development Housing development and associated works, 241 dwelling units.

Newtown Townland, Maynooth, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/2430
Applicant Sherwood Homes Lodged
Decided
29-07-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 209109 Planning Appeal
Development 165 dwellings
Capdoo Commons, Clane, Co. Kildare
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1636
Applicant Westar Investments Ltd Lodged
Decided
05-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 209438 Planning Appeal
Development Modification to and conversion of garage and change of use to physiotherapy clinic and sign.

59 Sallins Bridge, Sallins, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04\1889
Applicant Clodagh Quinn Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
08-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 209440 Planning Appeal
Development 3 no. 2 bed and 6 no. 3 bed houses in 2 no. 2 storey terraced blocks and site works.

Primrose Gate, Donaghcumper, Celbridge, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04\2008
Applicant Barina Construction Ltd. Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 10 210811 Planning Appeal
Development To re-arrange the layout and house types of 17 of the 21 houses, house numbers 3 to 19 inclusive.

Bennettsbridge, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1801
Applicant Patrick O'Brien Lodged
Decided
11-02-2005
10-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 10 211234 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing shed and derelict house and construct 28 houses.

Cottage Row, Graiguenamagh, Towland of Newpark, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1654
Applicant Charles Street Developments Limited. Lodged
Decided
11-03-2005
11-03-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 11 209644 Planning Appeal
Development Extend and renovate existing dwelling.

Moore Street, Rathdowney, Co.Laois.
Category
Planning Authority Laois County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1119
Applicant Nora Sweeney Lodged
Decided
11-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 209374 Planning Appeal
Development 3 no. houses and relocation of entrance to existing dwelling.

Knight Street, Ballingarry, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1741
Applicant Tadgh Keating Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 209433 Planning Appeal
Development Golf driving range, car parking and associated works.

Monaleen Road, Monaleen, Co. Limerick
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1316
Applicant Eugene Harrington Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 209400 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of dwelling over basement.

Ballyoonan, Omeath, Co. Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 041109
Applicant David McAnulty Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 16 211135 Planning Appeal
Development Sand and gravel quarry for a period of 50 years.

Ballynamarroge, Cloonkeen, OIslandeady, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1430
Applicant Roadstone Provinces Ltd. Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 17 209457 Planning Appeal
Development House, wastewater treatment unit, new common vehicular entrance for proposed house and adjoining house.

Killeaney, Kilcloon, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. DA/40295
Applicant John Nevin Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 18 211029 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to front and side of existing house with associated site works.

Ballingarry, Carrickmacross, Co. Monaghan.
Category
Planning Authority Monaghan County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/487
Applicant Finbar and Sheila Boylan Lodged
Decided
25-02-2005
09-03-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 19 209398 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of 30m high antennae support structure, antennae, equipment shelter, fencing, and access.

Charleston, Shannonsbridge, Co. Offaly
Category
Planning Authority Offaly County Council, Reg. Ref. 04\1136
Applicant Vodafone Ireland Limited Lodged
Decided
21-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 LV2367 Leave to Appeal S37(6)
Development 11 houses.

Creggaslin Townland, Castlerea, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1944
Applicant Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid-fee S.37(6)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 20 LV2368 Leave to Appeal S37(6)
Development 11 houses.

Creggaslin Townland, Castlerea, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1944
Applicant Lodged
Decided
08-03-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Invalid-fee S.37(6)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 22 209441 Planning Appeal
Development House, effluent treatment system, entrance and ancillary site works.

Castle Court, Terryglass, Nenagh, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 04510199
Applicant Paul and Ann O'Connor, Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 23 210146 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing dwelling and construct 207 no. 2 storey houses, neighbour centre, and new entrance onto roundabout.

Dundrum Road, Garnacarty, Tipperary Town.
Category
Planning Authority South Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/741
Applicant Barry Harte, Lodged
Decided
22-12-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 24 209334 Planning Appeal
Development House with sanitation system, septic tank.

Ballynamoyntragh, Dunmore East, Co. Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/1461
Applicant Thomas and Margaret Hennessey Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 24 209418 Planning Appeal
Development House with associated services, alter site sizes of existing developments reference numbers 182/01 and 889/02, use of existing
access on parents land.
Crooke, Passage East, Co. Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/675
Applicant Miriam Carey O'Callaghan Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 24 209583 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of house.

Mount Odell, Dungarvan, Co. Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1357
Applicant Tony and Eileen Craddock, Lodged
Decided
09-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 25 EL2036 Local authority non road development
Development Proposed Extension to Ballydonagh Landfill, Ballydonagh, Athlone, Co. Westmeath.

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Westmeath County Council Lodged
Decided
31-08-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Approve subject to conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 25C209368 Planning Appeal
Development House and proprietary wastewater treatment system.

Brownstown, Collinstown, Co. Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2120
Applicant Bruce Carroll Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 208734 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of access road in a revised position to serve 4 no. houses (previous reg. refs: 98/2779 & 2003/1083).

Tinnaberna, Ballynamona, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2003/4223
Applicant Killfair Limited and Belmoy Limited Lodged
Decided
06-09-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 209375 Planning Appeal
Development Two houses.

Churchtown, Templetown, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2004/0100
Applicant Tom O'Brien and Son Limited Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 211212 Planning Appeal
Development Waste recycling facility.

Coolatore, The Harrow, Enniscorthy, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2004/4903
Applicant Murray Waste Recycling Ltd. Lodged
Decided
11-03-2005
11-03-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 26 EL2029 Local authority non road development
Development Proposed Integrated Waste Management facility at Holmestown Forest, Co.Wexford

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Lodged
Decided
16-04-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Approve subject to conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 207973 Planning Appeal
Development House.

European Golf Club, Ardinary,Brittas Bay, Co.Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/715
Applicant Patrick Ruddy Junior Lodged
Decided
14-07-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 209412 Planning Appeal
Development Discount foodstore, leisure and fitness centre, retail and office units, parking and associated works.

Blacklion, Coolagad, Greystones, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1354
Applicant Lidl Ireland GmbH Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 210092 Planning Appeal
Development Delete conditions 2, 3, 7 and 8 of planning reference 04/947 for six no. houses.

Hazelwood, Johnstown, Kilpedder, Co.Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1593
Applicant Chevel Construction Lodged
Decided
20-12-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 211036 Planning Appeal
Development 2 storey extension to front and rear and retention of conservatory.

150 Hollybrook Park, Kilruddery, Bray, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1922
Applicant Áine Mc Carthy and Martin Gibbons, Lodged
Decided
25-02-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 211091 Planning Appeal
Development House, septic tank and percolation area.

Boleybawn, Tinahely, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1930
Applicant Ronan Rothwell, Lodged
Decided
01-03-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 211159 Planning Appeal
Development 8 no. houses and associated works.

Tomacork View Road, Carnew, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1170
Applicant Sea Consulting Limited, Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 28 207776 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from commercial to residential part demolition and alterations to hotel, demolish Belfort House and replace with new
house and construct 39 no. apartments with car park, new access
onto Middle Glanmire Rd.Arbutus Lodge, Middle Glanmire Road, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/27994
Applicant Grangefield Developments Limited Lodged
Decided
28-06-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 28 209436 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing buildings and construct 7 no. apartments with parking.

138-140 Lower Glanmire Road, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/28305
Applicant Maser Developments Limited Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 28 211113 Planning Appeal
Development Partial demolition of structures, extension to retain structures providing 2 commercial units and 6 no. apartments & construction
of 22 no apartments and works. 162 and 163 Sunday Wells Road,
Sundayside, Winters Hill, Sunday's Well Road, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/28400
Applicant Cumnor Construction Limited Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 28 211124 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of a 12 metre sculpture adjoining the Clarion Hotel

Lapps Quay, Clontarf Street, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/29128
Applicant Kilquane Limited Lodged
Decided
08-03-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 29N209442 Planning Appeal
Development Retain widening of existing vehicular entrance gateway.

10 St. Mobhi Drive, Glasnevin, Dublin 9.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 4126/04
Applicant Eamonn and Regina Gallagher, Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N209452 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish shop, with apartment over and house, and construct 5 storey 8x2 bed and 1x1 bed apartment over ground floor, retail
unit with basement and service yard.
80/81 Ballybough Road, corner of Charleville Avenue, Dublin 3.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 4054/04
Applicant Anthony Hardley, Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N209458 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing structures, construct 80 apartments in 5 storey block, consisting of 3 floors over retail, 82 car parking spaces,
53 cycle spaces and associated site works.
55-58 East Road, Dublin 3.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 4113/04
Applicant Michael McMahon, Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N209496 Planning Appeal
Development 1x2 storey 2 bed and 3x2 storey 1 bed apartments, 8 carparking spaces, reconfiguration of existing entrances and all associated
works.
48 - 50 Ardbeg Park, Artane, Dublin 5.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 4149/04
Applicant Thomas Keenan & John McDonnell, Lodged
Decided
02-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S208837 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing flat roofed extension and garage and construction of a new 3 storey extension to rear,2 storey
extension to return,double garage and associated works
3 Vergemount,Clonskeagh, Dublin 6
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 3514/04
Applicant Mantwood Investment Ltd., Lodged
Decided
14-09-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S209445 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing warehouse structure and the construction of a building consisting of 3 no. office units, 6 no. apartments,
parking and associated works.
3-5 Camden Place, Dublin 2.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 4065/04
Applicant C.Reilly,S.Byrne,A.Simpson and J.McKenzie. Lodged
Decided
27-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S209960 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from cafe bar and club to discount foodstore, advertising structures and associated works.

Rathmines Plaza Hotel, Rathmines road Lower, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 4658/04
Applicant Aldi Stores(Ireland)Ltd., Lodged
Decided
07-12-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 29SRA2004 Dispute Application Same Development
Development Whether an application for permission is the same development or development of the same description as that which is subject to
appeal PL29s.209445.
3-5 Camden Place, Dublin 2.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 5748/04
Applicant C. Reilly, S. Byrne, A. Simpson and J.McKenzie, Lodged
Decided
17-01-2005
10-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 30 209410 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use to licensed betting office and associated works.

39-40 Upper William Street, Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick City Council, Reg. Ref. 04/329
Applicant Ladbroke (IRL) Limited Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 30 211167 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use to creche and play area.

Old Winmill Road, Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick City Council, Reg. Ref. 04/502
Applicant Drumdarrig Holdings Ltd. & Trinity Properties Ltd., Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 36 209454 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use of existing ground floor retail shop to take-away.

Fenian Row, Ballina, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Ballina Town Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2525
Applicant Anthony Carr Lodged
Decided
29-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 37 209417 Planning Appeal
Development 17 no. houses and ancillary site works.

Derrymullan Townland, Ballinasloe, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Ballinasloe Town Council, Reg. Ref. 002/04
Applicant Gerard and Corina Dolan Lodged
Decided
26-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 38 209392 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing shop and construct 2 shop units and 2 no. 1st floor apartments and works

The Green, Birr, Co. Offaly.
Category
Planning Authority Birr Town Council, Reg. Ref. BR\1387
Applicant Paschal Campbell Lodged
Decided
22-10-2004
07-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 39 209595 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations to shopfront of premises which is a protected structure.

2 Goldsmith Terrace, Quinnsborough Road, Bray, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Bray Town Council, Reg. Ref. 04/94
Applicant Dunnes Stores, Lodged
Decided
10-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 58 211148 Planning Appeal
Development Drive-thru Restaurant.

Lifford, Gort Road, Ennis, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Ennis Town Council Reg. Ref. 03/194
Applicant McDonalds Restaurant of Ireland Ltd Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 61 208067 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing buildings and construct 6 no. apartments in a 3/4 storey building with protected structure, Cathedral River, to
the rear.
17 Nuns' Island Street, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 986/03
Applicant Cordil Construction Lodged
Decided
21-07-2004
10-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 61 209429 Planning Appeal
Development House.

54 Beach Court, Grattan Road, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 04/203
Applicant Tom O'Brien Lodged
Decided
28-10-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 61 210313 Planning Appeal
Development Changes to approved Baileypoint development, relevant register reference numbers: 98/425, 99/30, 99/399 and 00/92.

Upper Salthill, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 04/556
Applicant Granelt Properties Lodged
Decided
07-01-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Dismissed- Without Substance/Foundation S.138(1(a)(i)) EIS No
Board Ref. 61 FS0252 Fire Safety Certificate
Development Extension and material alteration retail, hotel, office and filling station.

Headford Road, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. FA2004/44
Applicant Roybride Properties Lodged
Decided
10-12-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn EIS No
Board Ref. 64 209613 Planning Appeal
Development Two houses and ancillary site works.

Cappa Village, Kilrush, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Kilrush Town Council Reg. Ref. 04/14
Applicant Tony Brew Lodged
Decided
10-11-2004
11-03-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 71 211182 Planning Appeal
Development Amemdments to aparthotel planning permission reg.ref PD5/02. Revised proposal 5 no.1 bedroom apartments, 34 no.3 bed hotel
suites and 9 duplex hotel suites.
The Mart Site (Market Green) Mogeesha, Co.Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Midleton Town Council Reg. Ref. 04/56038
Applicant Lodged
Decided
08-03-2005
08-03-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 77 207171 Planning Appeal
Development A mixed use scheme consisting of 136 residential units, 12 retail units and a public house (protected structures).

Connolly Street and Mail Coach Road, Sligo.
Category
Planning Authority Sligo Borough Council Reg. Ref. 156/03
Applicant JKR Developments Limited Lodged
Decided
17-05-2004
09-03-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 86 RL2232 Referral
Development Whether the parking of vehicles on the public road for business purposes is or is not development or is or is not exempt
development.
New Street, Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow Town Council Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
07-03-2005
Decision Invalid-fee S.5(3)(a) EIS No

End of Report. 102 Case(s)

16-Mar-2005 18:04

Last modified: 2007-03-22

Weekly lists
Planning Appeals
Other cases

All Planning Cases