An Bord Pleanála

Disposed cases. Week ended: 19th August 2005. Total cases: 111

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Board Ref. 02 211776 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from retail outlet to fish and chip shop/takeaway and associated works.

No. 1 Main Street, Ballyconnell, Co. Cavan.
Category
Planning Authority Cavan County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/94
Applicant Greg Phelan Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 02 211795 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing house and construct 104 units including a crecheand all associated site works.

Rahardrum and Ballaghanea, Virginia, Co. Cavan.
Category
Planning Authority Cavan County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2006
Applicant JH Craig Limited Lodged
Decided
15-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 209783 Planning Appeal
Development Provide basement, restaurant, delicatessen and coffee shop at ground, restaurant at first floor, living accommodation at second
floor, staff and public toilets.
1 Main Street, Lahinch, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. P04/933
Applicant Edel Hassett, Lodged
Decided
24-11-2004
19-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 03 210311 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from B&B to restaurant use,single storey extension with roof garden,extension to first floor area and all associated
site works, new ATM to front and demolish garden shed.
Ashtree House, Main Street, Doonbeg, County Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. P04/1704
Applicant Vertigo Conroy Ltd Lodged
Decided
07-01-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 CH2218 Compulsory Acq.under the Housing Act
Development Clare County Council (Ennis Northern Inner Relief Road - Phase 1) Compulsory Purchase Order 2005

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Clare County Council Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Clare County Council Lodged
Decided
14-07-2005
16-08-2005
Decision No objections Received EIS No
Board Ref. 04 211082 Planning Appeal
Development Helicopter hanger to the west of Cork Airport.

Ballygarvan, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. S/04/8833
Applicant Executive Helicopters ( Cork ) Ltd. Lodged
Decided
28-02-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 211799 Planning Appeal
Development Installation of waste disposal unit for thermal treatment of animal by-products and construction of extension to existing
abattoir and associated site works.
Derreenataggart East, Castletownbere, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6012
Applicant Joe Collins, Lodged
Decided
12-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 211843 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to house for use as doctors surgery.

Hunters Moon, Maryborough, Rochestown Road, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/9114
Applicant Conor Kiely, Lodged
Decided
18-04-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 213510 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to house.

Ringcurran House, Ardbrack, Kinsale, Co.Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3339
Applicant Barry and Philomena Coughlan Lodged
Decided
08-08-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 04 213613 Planning Appeal
Development House and fill and raise ground level.

Mansfield's Land, Kinsale, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3617
Applicant Lodged
Decided
16-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 04 CH2190 Compulsory Acq.under the Housing Act
Development Cork County Council R572 Road Improvements at Trafrask, Adrigole Beara Compulsory Purchase Order 2005.

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Cork County Council Lodged
Decided
10-03-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Confirm CPO without modifications EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05 212122 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of 6 no. houses and associated site works.

Mountcharles, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/221
Applicant Cathal McCosker Lodged
Decided
11-05-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 05A211728 Planning Appeal
Development House with waste water treatment system

Tandragee, Binnion, Clonmany, Lifford, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/4107
Applicant Charlie Doherty Lodged
Decided
12-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05A211734 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of 24m telecommunications tower, aerials, cabin and perimeter fence

Quigley's Point, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/4134
Applicant Radio Telefís Éireann Lodged
Decided
13-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05C211729 Planning Appeal
Development Refurbishment of derelict building to provide restaurant at ground floor level and 2 no apartments at first floor level.

Main Street, Carrigart, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/7779
Applicant Paul McBride Lodged
Decided
12-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D210084 Planning Appeal
Development Retail park including D.I.Y. store, garden centre, retail warehouse units, discount food store, gym, creche, offices, cafe
and car parking.
Former HB/Unilever Site, Whitehall Road, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0893
Applicant Bymac Project Managers Limited Lodged
Decided
20-12-2004
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211368 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing house and erection of 20 no. partments, carparking and associated site works.

Fey Yerra, Leopardstown Road, Foxrock, Dublin 18.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/1520
Applicant Strandsend Limited Lodged
Decided
16-03-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211556 Planning Appeal
Development House with off-street car parking.

16 Fairlawns, Saval Park, Dalkey, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/1221
Applicant Stephen Faul Lodged
Decided
24-03-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211561 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of stores to rear, construction of extension to shop. Change of use and extension to first floor, new shop front, car
parking and associated site works.
5 Newtown Park, Blackrock, Co. Dublin
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/1110
Applicant J.B. Gallagher Lodged
Decided
24-03-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211746 Planning Appeal
Development House and associated site works.

Cunningham Road, Dalkey, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0933
Applicant Jayne and Martin Courtney Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211750 Planning Appeal
Development House to side.

1 Monkstown Gate, Pakenham Road, Monkstown, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0814
Applicant Peter and Veronica O'Donoghue, Lodged
Decided
12-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211790 Planning Appeal
Development Retention for external alterations to 3 no. three bedroomed terraced houses, entrance gate and boundary wall.

26 Lower Churchtown Road, Churchtown, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0648
Applicant Ronald McCourt Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D213635 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of works at storey mews dwelling at rear of protected structure.

13 Eden Park, Glasthule, Co.Dublin
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0686
Applicant Sean Boyle Lodged
Decided
15-08-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 06F211397 Planning Appeal
Development Redevelopemnt of Bayside Neighbourhood Centre and Squash Centre involing demolition of all existing buildings and construction of
mixed use development of 3 blocks, including 13 retail units and
106 apartments. Bayside, Dublin 13.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. F04A/1819
Applicant Bayside Management Company Limited Lodged
Decided
16-03-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F211739 Planning Appeal
Development Two semi-detached bungalows with entrance from existing access offSwords Road and including modification of access from Swords Road,
car parking spaces and site ancillary works.
'Woodview', Swords Road, Malahide, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. F05A/0065
Applicant Elizabeth and Janet Mahon Lodged
Decided
12-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F213619 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of house to side of existing house

22 Rivervalley Rise, Forrest Road, Swords, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council Reg. Ref. F05A/0745
Applicant Mr. E.Breathnach Lodged
Decided
16-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 06F213707 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of change of use from shop to betting shop.

Unit 1, 4 Main Street, Swords, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council Reg. Ref. F05A/0778
Applicant Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 06F213718 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations, extension to include integration of original dwellingand granny flat, installation of velux windows, attic conversion,
all associated siteworks.
13 Carrickbrack, Lawn, Sutton, Dublin 13.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council Reg. Ref. F03B/0377
Applicant Mr. and Mrs. J.Raso Lodged
Decided
18-08-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 06S210382 Planning Appeal
Development Dwellinghouse and stables.

Pine Forest, Cruagh, Rockbrook, Rathfarnham, Dublin 16.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04/781
Applicant Frank O'Gorman Lodged
Decided
13-01-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S211804 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of house with garage and construct 2 houses with entrance wall and gate piers and all ancillary works.

3 Ballytore Road, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD05A/0043
Applicant Eugene and Marie Donohoe, Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S211807 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of extension and erection of house.

37 Fairbrook Lawn, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD05A/0069
Applicant Michael Kenny Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S211808 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of cellar, roof of extended cellar for beer garden, bar area to rear at ground level & COU of storage area for restaurant,
toilet block, glazed entrance porch, fire escape, ancillary works.
Courtney's Bar, Lucan. Road, Lucan, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0688
Applicant Hugh Courtney Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S211811 Planning Appeal
Development 3 houses.

166/167 St. Maelruan's Park, Tallaght, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0864
Applicant Des Nolan and Shay Murphy Lodged
Decided
15-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S212119 Planning Appeal
Development One and two storey extension to the side and rear incorporating new car port, 4 no. velux roof lights, elevational treatment and
site works.
Remax House, Gate Lodge, Old Rectory, Lucan, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0853
Applicant Andrew Healy Lodged
Decided
05-05-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 07 210938 Planning Appeal
Development Mixed development including 12 houses, 8 apartments, restaurant, gallery, shop, cafe, car parking
beachfront promenade with associated site works and services.
Seapoint, Bearna, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3066
Applicant Tom and J.P. Cunningham Lodged
Decided
22-02-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 211791 Planning Appeal
Development Park and ride facility comprising surface car parking, internal circulation roads, waiting room and services pavillion, effluent
treatment unit and ancillary services.
Sylaun, Headford Road, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/4101
Applicant Michael Collins Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 07 211796 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of elevational changes to house previously granted under reg.ref: 02/4625 and permission for 1st floor extension.

Lenarevagh, Barna, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/266
Applicant Martin Hession Lodged
Decided
13-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 211992 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing house and construct new dwellinghouse and septictank with wastewater treatment unit.

Oatfield Townland, Aughrim, Ballinasloe, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/279
Applicant Mark Manning Lodged
Decided
25-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 DT2030 Determination
Development Determination of amount payable by applicant to comply with condition no. 19 of PL 07.127325 relating to mixed development.

Trusky West and Ahaglugger, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 01/3510
Applicant Lodged
Decided
21-01-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Board decision EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 211817 Planning Appeal
Development Replace iron roof with slate and velux windows, new porch, extension to rear and install a mechanical aeration unit and soil
polishing filter.
Bushmount, Firies, Killarney, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 4344/04
Applicant Oliver Heffernan, Lodged
Decided
15-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 213263 Planning Appeal
Development Residential development consisting of 64 dwellings in total, administration office, tennis courts, roads, sewers and site
services.
Gortanora, Dingle, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council Reg. Ref. 4235/04
Applicant Southbound Properties Ltd. Lodged
Decided
20-07-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 09 211178 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of play school and car park.

Pollagorteen, Queensborough, Monasterevin, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1747
Applicant Patrick Havens Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 09 211763 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from retail unit to restaurant and takeaway.

Unit 1 Kildare Shopping Centre, Kildare Town, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2729
Applicant Anina Tanu and Joe Marsella Lodged
Decided
13-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 213675 Planning Appeal
Development School extension and construction of 35 bungalows

Cutbush, The Curragh, Co.Kildare
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council Reg. Ref. 04/1703
Applicant Ridgeway Homes Ltd Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 09 213710 Planning Appeal
Development 72 bedroom hotel

The Curragh Racecourse, The Curragh, Co. Kildare
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council Reg. Ref. 04/3072
Applicant Trustees of the Turf Club, Lodged
Decided
16-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no grounds S.127(1)(d) EIS No
Board Ref. 09 213711 Planning Appeal
Development Re-alignment of R413 road

The Curragh, Co. Kildare
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council Reg. Ref. 04/3137
Applicant Trustees of Turf Club, Lodged
Decided
16-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- subject matter not stated S.37(1)(c) EIS No
Board Ref. 09 LV2434 Leave to Appeal S37(6)
Development Change of use and refurbishment of buildings A, B and C.

Weston Aerodrome, Leixlip, Co.Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council Reg. Ref. 04/2141
Applicant Lodged
Decided
26-07-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Application for leave to appeal refused EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 RL2240 Referral
Development Whether extension to side of house is or is not development or is or is not exempt development.

Rear of 239 The Oaks, Ballymoney, Newbridge, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Bernard and Kerry Coogan Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Is development and is not exempted development EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 11 211764 Planning Appeal
Development Retain existing sales and storages yard and associated site works

Portlaoise Road, Portarlington, Co. Laois.
Category
Planning Authority Laois County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/78
Applicant Denis Ward Lodged
Decided
13-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 11 211880 Planning Appeal
Development Amend previous permission 98/542. Replace 32 semi-detached with 64no. 2 bed townhouses.

Kilminchey, Portlaoise, Co. Laois.
Category
Planning Authority Laois County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1574
Applicant Bresc Estates Lodged
Decided
19-04-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 211837 Planning Appeal
Development 8 no. houses.

The Grove, Abbeyfeale, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/37
Applicant Robert O' Brien, Lodged
Decided
20-04-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 14 211290 Planning Appeal
Development House, garage and associated site works.

Clonterm, Longford, Co. Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1250
Applicant Eamon McCoppin and Margaret Kelly Lodged
Decided
15-03-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 14 211760 Planning Appeal
Development 35 no. houses.

Creevaghbeg, Ballymahon, Co. Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1075
Applicant West of Ireland Developments Limited, Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 14 211902 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Newpark, Lanesboro, Co. Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1092
Applicant Peter Murtagh, Lodged
Decided
18-04-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 14 212946 Planning Appeal
Development Mixed residential development consisting of 125no. dwelling units with creche, landscaping, associated service roads, ancillary
works and storm water attenuation tanks.
Tinnynarr, Edgeworthstown, Co. Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council Reg. Ref. 04/1060
Applicant Charles Clancy Lodged
Decided
28-06-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Application withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 15 211702 Planning Appeal
Development 4 no 2 bedroom semi-detached dwellings, 2 no retail units and 2 no. office units, 11 no. car parking spaces, signage and ancillary
site works.
Lower Main Street, Dunleer, Co. Louth
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1019
Applicant Grangevale Enterprises Limited Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 16 213132 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Glaspatrick, Murrisk, Westport, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council Reg. Ref. 05/518
Applicant Joseph Terrence Geoghegan, Lodged
Decided
15-07-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 16 213479 Planning Appeal
Development House, septic tank and percolation area.

Lackafinna, Cong, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council Reg. Ref. 04/3214
Applicant Dominic and Lila Smyth Lodged
Decided
02-08-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 16 213645 Planning Appeal
Development House, septic tank and percolation area.

Salin, Achill, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council Reg. Ref. 05/1519
Applicant Brian McNamera, Lodged
Decided
19-08-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 17 210877 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of altered position of building position of building on site granted under planning permission no. TA-30235.

Kilballivor, Main Street, Ballivor, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. TA/40372
Applicant Brendan Bagnall Lodged
Decided
14-02-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 211354 Planning Appeal
Development Golf course, tennis academy, club house, 28 holiday homes,and sitesewerage treatment plant, machine storage shed, pedestrian
underpass, site access.
Ashpark/Moorepark, Garristown, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. NA/40544
Applicant Kilmoon Investments Ltd. Lodged
Decided
18-03-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 WW0295 Water Pollution Licence - Waters
Development Discharge of treated sewage effluent to the Delvin River.

Gormanston, County Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. DL04/10
Applicant Noonan Construction Limited Lodged
Decided
08-02-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Refuse appeal EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 19 211761 Planning Appeal
Development 6 no. dwelling houses and site works extend roads.

Derryvilla, Portarlington, Co. Offaly.
Category
Planning Authority Offaly County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/26
Applicant Evan Bennett Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 19 211879 Planning Appeal
Development Develop sand and gravel pit-(a) retain batching plant and fuel tanks (b) relocate entrance (c) provide office (d) washdown
facility (e) effluent system.
Whigsborough, Fivealley, Birr, Co. Offaly.
Category
Planning Authority Offaly County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/87
Applicant Smyths Sand and Gravel Limited Lodged
Decided
19-04-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 131518 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Claheen Townland, Cootehall, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 99/905
Applicant Sean Mc Weeney, Lodged
Decided
18-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 20 213704 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of house and construction of 6 no. 2 bedroom apartments.

Demesne, Castlerea, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council Reg. Ref. 04/2120
Applicant Anna Doherty, Lodged
Decided
19-08-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 22 211786 Planning Appeal
Development House and effluent treatment system.

Drumgower Horse & Jockey, Thurles, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/51/0075
Applicant Peter & Elaine Broderick Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 22 211787 Planning Appeal
Development 14 Houses.

Pallas Beg, Newtown, Nenagh, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 04511496
Applicant Pallasbeg Properties Ltd. Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 22 213719 Planning Appeal
Development 60M high temporary wind montoring mast for 3 years.

Castlewaller, Newport, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council Reg. Ref. 05510612
Applicant Angela Coffey & David Coffey Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 25M213629 Planning Appeal
Development 15 houses, road, footpath, carparking.
Ballindurrow, Multyfarnham, Co. Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council Reg. Ref. 04/5477
Applicant Stephen Vambeck Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 26 210407 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of two houses.

Ballymoney Upper, Courtown, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2004/3877
Applicant Prospect Homes (Ballymoney) Limited Lodged
Decided
17-01-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 211780 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing house, construction of 16 houses and changeof use of 2 existing outbuildings from storage to accomodation
and sewerage treatment plant.
Clonhenret, Kilcomb, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2004/3672
Applicant Fercon Property Developments Ltd. Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 212841 Planning Appeal
Development 77 houses, creche and asociated site works.

Castleland, Ferns, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2004/4476
Applicant John and David Kavanagh, Lodged
Decided
27-06-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 26 213687 Planning Appeal
Development Two houses and associated site works.

Crossfarnogue, Kilmore Quay, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council Reg. Ref. 2005/2028
Applicant Dan and Mary Carbery, Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 26 213705 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and change of use form commercial wharehousing to builders store, recycling unit and alterations.

Ballygillane Beg, St. Helen's, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council Reg. Ref. 2004/4657
Applicant Goff Recycling Ltd., Lodged
Decided
16-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 26 CH2217 Compulsory Acq.under the Housing Act
Development County Wexford Compulsory Purchase (Ballymurry) Order No.1 of 2005in the County of Wexford

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Wexford County Council Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Wexford County Council Lodged
Decided
12-07-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Annul CPO EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 FS0258 Fire Safety Certificate
Development Condition number 2 of F088/2004 to be materially altered without providing the lobby at the base of the stairs.

Bessmount, Killoughrim, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. F028/2005
Applicant Liam Griffin Lodged
Decided
18-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Allow appeal with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 210160 Planning Appeal
Development Office, business and science and technology park (protected structure).

Mount Kennedy Demesne, Kilpedder, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/9406
Applicant Dryfield Limited, Lodged
Decided
22-12-2004
16-08-2005
Decision 1st Refuse permission EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 212874 Planning Appeal
Development Creche and associated works.

Giltspur Lane, Southern Cross Road, Bray, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/2652
Applicant P. Ryan, D. Colgan, F. McDonne & Philip Monaghan Lodged
Decided
28-06-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 213642 Planning Appeal
Development Funeral home.

Whitefield, Tinahely, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/2713
Applicant Martin Doyle Lodged
Decided
19-08-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 213644 Planning Appeal
Development House at side of existing dwelling and associated works.

No.50 Rockfield Park, Kilmacanogue, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3015
Applicant David Mahon Lodged
Decided
18-08-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 213652 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to rear of dwelling.

No.5 Mill Bank, Killincarrig, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3012
Applicant Kathleen Harte Lodged
Decided
19-08-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 28 211699 Planning Appeal
Development Construct 4 houses, extend existing shop, demolish portion of existing residential, construct 4 apartments on 3 floors

1,2 and 3 Westbourne, College Road and Highfield Road, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/28769
Applicant Ann Clifford Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 28 213660 Planning Appeal
Development 15m high monopole with antennae and dishes, also with cabinets, fencing and associated equipment.

Crosbie Transcars, Tivoli Industrial Estate, Tivoli, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 05/29727
Applicant Hutchinson 3G Ireland Limited Lodged
Decided
18-08-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 29N211420 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of dwelling and construct 4 storey penthouse building, 11 student dwelling units, 1 caretaker unit and works.

112A Upper Drumcondra Rd. Dublin 9.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 6119/04
Applicant Shane & Simon Carthy, Lodged
Decided
23-03-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N211445 Planning Appeal
Development 16 no. apartments in a 3 storey block; 8 no. terraced houses and all associated site works.

694 Howth Road, Dublin 5.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 4978/04
Applicant Mr. E Farrelly, Lodged
Decided
22-03-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N211769 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing warehouse and storage buildings, construct 4 no.blocks ranging in height from 2 to 4 stories and to include 44
residential units.
151 - 169, Richmond Road, Fairview, Dublin 3.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 3388/04
Applicant Stella Trust Ltd. Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N211772 Planning Appeal
Development 2 no. 1.3m face mounted antennae, 1 no. 1.3m pole mounted antenna and 3 no. 0.3 m pole mounted radio link dishes and associated
equipment (protected structure).
The Comfort Inn, Denmark Street Great, Dublin 1.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1179/05
Applicant Hutchison 3 G Ireland Ltd. Lodged
Decided
12-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211293 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing buildings and construction of a 4 Storey building featuring retail unit, retail/salon/clinic unit 3 no.
apartments and associated works.
27/29 Dunville Avenue, Rathmines, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 5853/04
Applicant John Kavanagh, Lodged
Decided
15-03-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 29S211495 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of steel boiler flue ( a protected structure).

170 Rathmines Road Upper, Rathmines, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1073/05
Applicant Maeve O Carroll Lodged
Decided
24-03-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211753 Planning Appeal
Development Partial demolition of 1st floor level, 2 apartments on 1st floor, 4 no. apartments on additional second floor, roof garden, access
and associated works(within curtilage of protected structures 76&
77 Merrion Sq)Mc Grattans Restaurant,76 Fitzwilliam lane,Dublin 2.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 3744/04
Applicant Dan McGrattan, Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211757 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of 2 no.two storey mews houses with parking to rear of existing premises and access via Annesley Park.

41-43 Dunville Avenue, Ranelagh, Dublin 6.(A Protected Structure)
Category Protected structure
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1232/05
Applicant Pat Halpin, Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211758 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of rear returns, Construction of new rear returns, internal and external alterations, change of use of apartments to
a three storey "E Learning" centre and associated works.
51 Waterloo Road, Dublin 4.(A Protected Structure)
Category Protected structure
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1183/05
Applicant Paul Rowland Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211816 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing sheds and a portion of a boundary wall and construction of 2 no. two-storey mews houses with parking and
associated works.
52-54 Garville Lane, Rathgar, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1251/05
Applicant Helen Brannigan, Lodged
Decided
18-04-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S213628 Planning Appeal
Development 2no. mews houses at rear.

37 Mountpleasant Avenue Lower, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 3084/05
Applicant Tony O'Hara Lodged
Decided
15-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 29SRL2228 Referral
Development Whether the installation of replacement windows in the front elevation of the existing dwelling is or is not development or is
or is not exempted development.
2 Grosvenor Road, Rathmines, Dublin 6.(A Protected Structure)
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 0031/05
Applicant Robert Houlihan, Lodged
Decided
02-03-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Is development and is exempted development EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 30 213654 Planning Appeal
Development 2 no. houses and associated works.

Rhebogue Road, Rhebogue.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick City Council Reg. Ref. 05/52
Applicant McCarthy & Woulfe Limited Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 31 211794 Planning Appeal
Development Renovation, refurbishment and extension to commercial building (Protected Structure).

43-44 Michael Street, Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford City Council, Reg. Ref. 04/530
Applicant Allied Irish Banks Plc. Lodged
Decided
13-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 31 213674 Planning Appeal
Development Conversion of the attic to 3 no. bedrooms, storage and en-suite, replacement of existing roof with new roof, and two storey
extension to rear of house and all associated works.
6 Pleasant Drive, Mount Pleasant, Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford City Council Reg. Ref. 05/132
Applicant Sabrina Douglas Lodged
Decided
17-08-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 44 211742 Planning Appeal
Development 70 Houses.

Knocknaconnery, Greenhill Village, Carrick-on-Suir, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Carrick-on-suir Town Council, Reg. Ref. PD04/110
Applicant Martin Brophy, Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 46 210919 Planning Appeal
Development Alteration and extension to existing retail premises with associated site works and services.

Ellison Street, Castlebar, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Castlebar Town Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3220
Applicant Heatons Ltd. Lodged
Decided
15-02-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 52 211732 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of stone wall and railings, timber summer house beside main house.

Mountain View, Abbey Road, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Clonmel Town Council, Reg. Ref. 05/8
Applicant Muiris & Dewi O'Loingsigh Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 53 212210 Planning Appeal
Development House within the curtilage of Wilmount House(proposed protected structure).

Wilmount Avenue, Cobh, Co.Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cobh Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/52015
Applicant Declan and Carol Carlos Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 61 131536 Planning Appeal
Development Construct 3 apartments and associated services to rear of house and construct an entrance off roadway to rear (O.P.P. 500/97).

Villanova, Upper Salthill, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 01/381
Applicant Davoren & Keary Construction Lodged
Decided
14-07-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn EIS No
Board Ref. 61 211395 Planning Appeal
Development Store to rear of hotel

Harbour Hotel, The Docks, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 04/1025
Applicant John Lally Lodged
Decided
18-03-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 61 211798 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to factory, new entrance and security fencing with associated site works; retention of ESB substation and switch
room.
Penn Engineering, Mervue Business Park, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 04/964
Applicant Penn Engineering Fastening Technologies Lodged
Decided
14-04-2005
17-08-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 61 213673 Planning Appeal
Development A two storey rear extension incorporating a bed sit and office accommodation, change of use for the remainder of building from
house to office space.
16 University Road, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 05/369
Applicant Galway Diocesan Trustees Lodged
Decided
18-08-2005
18-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 65 211726 Planning Appeal
Development Renovation & conservation of Custom House Building, C.O.U to hotel, construction of 3 & 2 storey annex, associated parking and
site works. Custom House, junction of Lower O' Connell Street,
adjacent to the Trident Hotel, Kinsale, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Kinsale Town Council Reg. Ref. 04/53027
Applicant Courtenay and Valerie Good Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 66 LV2440 Leave to Appeal S37(6)
Development Road depot and salt barn.

Ballyraine, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Letterkenny Town Council Reg. Ref. L11/05
Applicant Lodged
Decided
15-08-2005
15-08-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.37(6)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 68 213626 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of retail development with car parking and associatedservices and site works.

Dublin Road, Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford Town Council Reg. Ref. 04/98
Applicant Ireland Holiday Motels Ltd. Lodged
Decided
16-08-2005
16-08-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 74 213353 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish sheds and structures and construct 16 apartments, 19 parking spaces.

Rear of 64 Ormond Street, Nenagh, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Nenagh Town Council Reg. Ref. 04524219
Applicant Seamus Ryan Lodged
Decided
26-07-2005
19-08-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No

End of Report. 111 Case(s)

24-Aug-2005 16:44

Last modified: 2007-03-22

Weekly lists
Planning Appeals
Other cases

All Planning Cases