An Bord Pleanála

Disposed cases. Week ended: 23rd September 2005. Total cases: 116

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Board Ref. 01 212286 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish house, construct dormer dwelling, entrance and proprietary treatment unit.

Carrigslaney, Killbride, Co. Carlow.
Category
Planning Authority Carlow County Council, Reg. Ref. PL/04-691
Applicant Rose Cummins, Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 211733 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Bearnafunshin, Barefield, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. P04/1943
Applicant Paul Brodie, Lodged
Decided
11-04-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 211814 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Portdrine, Cratloe, Co. Clare
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. P04/1646
Applicant Colm Finn Lodged
Decided
15-04-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 212274 Planning Appeal
Development House with treatment unit & associated site works.

Church Road, Newquay, Burren, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/332
Applicant Philip & Audrey Champ. Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 CH2205 Compulsory Acq.under the Housing Act
Development Clare County Council (Wastewater Treatment Plant, Clareabbey, Clarecastle, Ennis) Compulsory Purchase Order 2005.

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Clare County Council Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Objections withdrawn EIS No
Board Ref. 04 212319 Planning Appeal
Development Car showroom, workshop, offices, canteen, carwash, new vehicular entrance, treatment plant and associated signage.

Baltydaniel West, New Twopothouse, Mallow, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/168
Applicant John O' Flynn Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212326 Planning Appeal
Development House and garage.

Clonclud, Macroom, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/1154
Applicant Fiona Kelleher and Kieran Coffey Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212327 Planning Appeal
Development House

Liscahane, Millstreet, Co. Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6250
Applicant Nicholas Buckley Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212328 Planning Appeal
Development House

Inchydoney Island,Clonakilty, Co. Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/9562
Applicant Patricia & Tony McCarthy Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 213912 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish 2 no. houses, construct 55 no. residential units, 2 no. serviced sites, creche, medical centre, 3 no. retail units, car
parking and associated site works.
Skull, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 05/1839
Applicant Richard Walsh Lodged
Decided
02-09-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 05 131533 Planning Appeal
Development 5 no dwellings, septic tank, effluent treatment unit and surface water attentuation system.

Rossnowlagh Upper, Rossnowlagh, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council Reg. Ref. 05/452
Applicant Hugh John Patton Lodged
Decided
07-07-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Dismissed-s.14(1)(b)nature of appeal/previous permission EIS No
Board Ref. 05A214153 Planning Appeal
Development House, garage and septic tank

Aught, Muff, Lifford, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council Reg. Ref. 04/5592
Applicant John McCauley Lodged
Decided
20-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 05B210742 Planning Appeal
Development Retention & completion of change of use from shop to entertainmentlounge bar, staff room, toilets and service kitchen.
Ramsay's Stores, The Harbour, Market Square, Dunfanaghey,
Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3584
Applicant Daniel and Ann Sweeney Lodged
Decided
09-02-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05B210743 Planning Appeal
Development Retention & completion of change of use from shop to off sales and bar.
Ramsay's Store, The Harbour, Market Square, Dunfanaghey,
Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3629
Applicant Daniel and Ann Sweeney Lodged
Decided
09-02-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Direction(2)
Board Ref. 05B211599 Planning Appeal
Development Removal of existing dwelling and construction of new dwelling, septic tank and percolation area.

Cashelgolan, Portnoo, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2943
Applicant P.J. (Senior) and H. McHugh Lodged
Decided
30-03-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05B212359 Planning Appeal
Development House with treatment system

Keadew, Burtonport, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3590
Applicant Mickey Doherty Lodged
Decided
26-05-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05C212333 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of a house under construction.

Croaghross, Portsalon, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/7086
Applicant Ailbe and Brigid Flynn Lodged
Decided
24-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05D212267 Planning Appeal
Development House, garage and septic tank

Balleeghan, Manorcunningham, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/6029
Applicant Colin Brogan Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D210483 Planning Appeal
Development 14 no. houses and 2 apartments, improvements to existing entrance,demolition of rear extension and other associated site works.
Eaton Brae House (protected structure), Eaton Brae, Shankill,
Co. Dublin.
Category Protected structure
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/0804
Applicant Eugene B. Costelloe and Others. Lodged
Decided
21-01-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211693 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from retail unit to a betting office.

Osprey Court, Dublin Road, Shankill, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0034
Applicant Paddy Power Bookmakers PLC Lodged
Decided
05-04-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D211695 Planning Appeal
Development 6 no. apartments in 2 blocks (previously approved under Reg. Ref. D03A/0910 and Reg. Ref. D00A/1094, PL06D.126709), car parking and
site works. Rear of 21 & 23 Johnstown Road and 115 Granitefield,
Dun Laoghaire, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/1395
Applicant Ellen Construction Limited Lodged
Decided
07-04-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 06D211839 Planning Appeal
Development Residential development of 21 no. apartments in two blocks with car parking, accesses and site development works including
demolition of building on site.
Annaville Avenue, Blackrock, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0109
Applicant Des O'Donnell Lodged
Decided
19-04-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D212242 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to rear.

1A Albert Road Lower, Sandycove, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05B/0126
Applicant K. Nowlan and K. Foynes Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D212315 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of 2 shed structures and roadside boundary wall and vehicular access gates.

14 Dublin Road, Bray, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0254
Applicant J and G Dowling Lodged
Decided
23-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D214189 Planning Appeal
Development House on a site at rear incorporating existing main entrance with two additional off street car spaces.

77 Churchtown Road, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0857
Applicant Kay McGuinness Lodged
Decided
19-09-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 06D214194 Planning Appeal
Development Refurbishment and extension of existing dwelling.

14 Village Gate, Dalkey, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05B/0299
Applicant Mary Brophy Lodged
Decided
20-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 06D214228 Planning Appeal
Development House on a site at rear incorporating existing main entrance with two additional off street car spaces.

77 Churchtown Road, Dublin 14.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0857
Applicant Kay McGuinness Lodged
Decided
21-09-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 06F212235 Planning Appeal
Development House with new boundary walls, site entrance and associated site works to the rear of existing house.

90, St. Peter's Terrace, Howth, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. F04A/0827
Applicant James Haugh, Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F212236 Planning Appeal
Development Modifications/Revisions to two blocks of apartments (Zone 12 Blocks 1 and 2) four stories high over basement carpark under
existing permission (Reg.Ref: F02A/1255; PL 06F.202469).
Former Phoenix Park Racecourse, Ashtown, Dublin 15.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. F05A/0232
Applicant Flynn and O'Flaherty Dublin, Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F212270 Planning Appeal
Development Residential development consisting of 59 no. houses and all on & off site development works.

Rowlestown, Swords, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. F04A/1525
Applicant Eastern Homes Limited Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06F213909 Planning Appeal
Development Extension and conversion of attic.
77 Biscayne, Malahide, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council Reg. Ref. F05B/0398
Applicant N and M Barry Lodged
Decided
02-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 06S212211 Planning Appeal
Development Internal alterations comprising extension to the existing mezzanine floor by 563 sqm for ancillary storage use.
Unit 9a, Liffey Valley Retail Park, Liffey Valley, Clondalkin,
Dublin 22.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD05A/0143
Applicant Argos Ltd. Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S212384 Planning Appeal
Development Single storey extension to pre-school facility large ground floor window to be replaced with an entrance door and smaller window.

3 Hermitage Gardens, Lucan, Co.Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD05A/0172
Applicant Helena Goodwin Lodged
Decided
25-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S212388 Planning Appeal
Development Retain aluminium entrance doors and signage to the entrance doors,the signage above the entrance doors and signage on the side
elevation at Salon Services.
1 Wilton Park Works, Robinhood Road, Dublin 22.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD05A/0064
Applicant Salon Services Lodged
Decided
24-05-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 211591 Planning Appeal
Development Construct a dwelling house and septic tank,

Coolnaharragill Upper, Glenbeigh, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2323
Applicant Jim Diggin, Lodged
Decided
30-03-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Direction(2)
Board Ref. 08 212233 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing buildings & permission to construct 1 no. retailunit and 4 no. apartments with all associated ancillary services &
site works.
31a Longford Street, Killorglin, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2446
Applicant P K D Construction Ltd. Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212248 Planning Appeal
Development Construct a dwellinghouse served by a septic tank and percolation area.

Glenderry, Ballyheigue, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/572
Applicant Frank Kenny, Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212256 Planning Appeal
Development 24m high slim-line lattice tower, carrying antennae and associatedequipment within a fenced compound and access track.

Knockaclare, Lyracrumpane, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/526
Applicant Vodafone Ireland Ltd. Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212281 Planning Appeal
Development Dwelling with septic tank.

Rockfield Middle, Killarney, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/410
Applicant Margaret and Tim Mc Carthy Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212284 Planning Appeal
Development 7 no. detached houses with treatment units.

Ballyfinnane, Firies, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/4495
Applicant Matra Construction Ltd Lodged
Decided
23-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212411 Planning Appeal
Development 15.25m high lattice tower with antennas and fenced compound.

Killurley West, Caherciveen, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 711/05
Applicant Radio Telefís Éireann Lodged
Decided
30-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 09 212455 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Mullaghroe Upper, Monasterevin, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/18
Applicant Padraic Merlehan, Lodged
Decided
31-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Dismissed -prescribed body not entitled to appeal S.37(4)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 10 209848 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to existing shed with slatted accommodation and slurry tank and all ancillary works.

Brownsbarn, Thomastown, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1433
Applicant Joe Bookle, Lodged
Decided
29-11-2004
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 10 212260 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish 2 no. houses and construct 32 no. houses together with associated siteworks.

Mallfield Grennan, Thomastown, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1381
Applicant S.E. Construction Ltd., Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 10 212626 Planning Appeal
Development Mixed use development comprising 563 no. houses, a village centre and a nursing home/retirement village.

Rathculliheen, Kilkenny South, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 03/1711
Applicant Jeremiah O' Reilly and Associates Limited Lodged
Decided
10-06-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS Yes
Board Ref. 11 211347 Planning Appeal
Development 806 dwellings, 6 retail units and creche, site works etc.

Fruithill, Graiguecullen, Co. Laois.
Category
Planning Authority Laois County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/6
Applicant Clayborne Properties Limited Lodged
Decided
21-03-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 12 211326 Planning Appeal
Development Construct house, domestic garage, septic tank, percolation area, entrance from public road, walls, site boundaries and all
associated works.
Fohera Lane, Cannaboe Td, Ballinamore, Co. Leitrim.
Category
Planning Authority Leitrim County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1712
Applicant John C Martin Senior Lodged
Decided
16-03-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 12 212008 Planning Appeal
Development Construct new house, connect to public services and ancillary siteworks.

Amorset Td, Manorhamilton, Co. Leitrim.
Category
Planning Authority Leitrim County Council, Reg. Ref. P04/1333
Applicant Desmond McDermott Lodged
Decided
29-04-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Direction
Board Ref. 12 212314 Planning Appeal
Development Retain and complete a storey and a half house, septic tank and a proprietary sewage treatment system, site entrance and works.

Diffreen, Glencar, Co. Leitrim.
Category
Planning Authority Leitrim County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/14
Applicant John McTaggart Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 131535 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Carnane, Fedamore, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council Reg. Ref. 05/1189
Applicant Caroline Bradshaw. Lodged
Decided
12-07-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse approval EIS No
View the Order
Board Ref. 13 214110 Planning Appeal
Development House, storage building, sewage treatment system and percolation area.
Meentulla, Murroe, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council Reg. Ref. 05/1819
Applicant Oonagh Walsh and Glenn Hooper Lodged
Decided
14-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 14 212297 Planning Appeal
Development House, entrance, waste water system with percolation area and siteworks.

Clonnart South, Bornacolla, Co. Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/53
Applicant Gavin Reilly and Ann Marie Cox Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 14 212539 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from stables/farm stores to 13no Residential holiday units to include partial demolition of existing buildings with
ancillary services and site works.
Rathcline House, Lanesboro, Co. Longford
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1069
Applicant Maureen Kearns Lodged
Decided
08-06-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 211004 Planning Appeal
Development 54 no. dwelling units and associated site development works.

Hamilton, Rock Road, Blackrock, Dundalk, Co. Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1121
Applicant McGahon Partnership Lodged
Decided
24-02-2005
20-09-2005
Decision 1st Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 212194 Planning Appeal
Development House

Drummullagh, Omeath, Co. Louth
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/192
Applicant Patrick Walker Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 212195 Planning Appeal
Development House

Ardagh, Tullyallen, Co. Louth
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1638
Applicant Gary Stewart and Geraldine McAleer Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Dismissed-nature of appeal/any previous permission S.138(1)(b) EIS No
View the Report
Board Ref. 15 213525 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to side of dwelling, conversion and extension of existing garage to a T.V. room and 1 no. bedroom and all
associated site works.
1 Woodbrook, Sandpit, Termonfeckin, Co. Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council Reg. Ref. 05/240
Applicant Adel and Thora El Sayed. Lodged
Decided
10-08-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Application withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 15 214144 Planning Appeal
Development Retention for existing temporary entrance gates and fencing off the Collon Road for use as temporary access to contractors site
offices
Gleann Alainn, Drogheda Road, Tullyallen, Co. Louth
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council Reg. Ref. 05/907
Applicant Euro Construction Corporation Limited Lodged
Decided
19-09-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 16 212393 Planning Appeal
Development Helicopter hangar and helicopter landing area and ancillary works.

Cordarragh, Kiltimagh, Co. Mayo
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3024
Applicant Paul Walsh Lodged
Decided
24-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 16 212491 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Ballynacarriga, Sheeaune, Westport, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/691
Applicant Gerry and Ann Corcoran, Lodged
Decided
02-06-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 16 214178 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Lecarrow, Newport, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council Reg. Ref. 05/1746
Applicant Laurence Kilbane and Anne-Marie Goggins Lodged
Decided
20-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 17 212217 Planning Appeal
Development 8 houses and ancillary site works.

Kingsgate, Duleek, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. SA/40438
Applicant Vincent Matthews Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 17 212306 Planning Appeal
Development House, double garage, Ecopure system and entrance.

Raynestown, Dunshaughlin, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. DA/50086
Applicant Amanda Wynne Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 212507 Planning Appeal
Development House, proprietary effluent treatment system, new roadside entrance, associated site works, to side garden of existing
house, remove existing septic tank.
Muckerstowm, The Ward, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. DA/50108
Applicant Marcus Sweeney Lodged
Decided
03-06-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 213414 Planning Appeal
Development 3 phase mixed use commercial/residential development, surface water sewers, landscaping and all associated works.

Duleek, Co.Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council Reg. Ref. SA/40521
Applicant Seamus Kavanagh Lodged
Decided
29-07-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Dismissed-nature of appeal/any previous permission S.138(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 18 212106 Planning Appeal
Development 54 houses and 9 apartments.

Nafarty, Ballybay Road, Carrickmacross, Co. Monaghan.
Category
Planning Authority Monaghan County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1441
Applicant McMahon and Eakin Ltd. Lodged
Decided
03-05-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 19 212400 Planning Appeal
Development House and domestic garage.

Erry, Armstrong, Clara, Co. Offaly
Category
Planning Authority Offaly County Council, Reg. Ref. PL2/05/238
Applicant Ross Fitzpatrick Lodged
Decided
26-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 211535 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Gorttoose, Scramogue, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2464
Applicant Anthony O'Gara Lodged
Decided
23-03-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 211947 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Gortgallon Townland, Ballyleague, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1731
Applicant Betty Murphy Lodged
Decided
28-04-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 212398 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of a house and construction of a house.

Killinordan Townland, Scramogue, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2529
Applicant Kieran Leavy Lodged
Decided
25-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 213949 Planning Appeal
Development 8 no. houses and ancillary site works.

Lavagh Townland, Rooskey, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council Reg. Ref. 04/2369
Applicant Anne McDonagh Lodged
Decided
05-09-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 21 212303 Planning Appeal
Development House, garage, septic tank and ancillary site works.

Rathglass, Enniscrone, Co. Sligo.
Category
Planning Authority Sligo County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/130
Applicant Anthony and Elaine Price Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 21 212406 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from dwelling to creche and extension to house.

4 The Orchard, Sea Road, Sligo
Category
Planning Authority Sligo County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/137
Applicant Ann Carton Lodged
Decided
23-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 23 212271 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Shanaclune, Cappawhite, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority South Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/196
Applicant Eugene O'Neill Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 23 212298 Planning Appeal
Development House and garage.

Fennor, Urlingford, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority South Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/229
Applicant Michael Purcell Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Direction
Board Ref. 24 211393 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing house, construction of 3-storey, four bedroom house with associated site works and services.

Inchindrisla, Dungarvan, Co. Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1994
Applicant Michael Ryan Lodged
Decided
18-03-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 24 212300 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations to existing permission (03/1807) for proposed hospital development.

Butlerstown North, Cork Road, Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2020
Applicant Eurocare International Ltd. Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 25 214224 Planning Appeal
Development 23 no. houses, 15 no. apartments, 15 no. maisonettes, parking.

Clonbrusk, Coosan, Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council Reg. Ref. 04/3198
Applicant Athway Construction Lodged
Decided
19-09-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 25A212093 Planning Appeal
Development Warehouse/Light industrial development.

Tullaghnageeragh, Moate, Co. Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/1035
Applicant E & G Developments Ltd. Lodged
Decided
06-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 25C210490 Planning Appeal
Development Permanent retention of Karting Track.

Lisclogher Little, Delvin, County Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2300
Applicant John O'Neill, Brian Carey, Pat Engoldsby Lodged
Decided
17-01-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 25C212299 Planning Appeal
Development 8 town houses, 4 offices & associated site works to rear of Polland Arms ( a protected structure).

Mullingar Road, Castlepollard, Co. Westmeath.
Category Protected structure
Planning Authority Westmeath County Council Reg. Ref. 04/2075
Applicant Frank Pratt Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 214174 Planning Appeal
Development Granny flat and associated site works.

Shelmaliere Commons, Carrick, Co. Wexford.
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council Reg. Ref. 2005/1272
Applicant William O'Neill Lodged
Decided
20-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 27 214171 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish sheds and construct 3 no. dwellings. Riverdale, Lower Street, Aughrim, Co. Wicklow.

Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3106
Applicant Kevin Mann and Pat Canavan Lodged
Decided
21-09-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 DT2031 Determination
Development Determination of the amount payable by the applicant to comply with condition no. 20 of PL27.103841.

Mullinaveigue, Roundwood, Co. Wicklow
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 97/6166
Applicant Kevin Devlin Lodged
Decided
13-09-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Invalid-fee EIS No
Board Ref. 28 212294 Planning Appeal
Development Provision of a 9 metre totem sign adjacent to the Wilton Roundabout.
Wilton Shopping Centre, Bishopstown Road and Sarsfield Road,
Bishopstown, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/28847
Applicant Tesco Ireland Limited Lodged
Decided
23-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 28 212341 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing bank premises, construction of a new bank building, new signage, relocation of ATM facility, provision of 17
no staff car parking spaces and associated works.
O'Connell Street and Watercourse Road, Blackpool, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 05/29418
Applicant Allied Irish Bank Plc Lodged
Decided
25-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N210853 Planning Appeal
Development 3 no. apartments and associated site works.

158 Capel Street, Dublin 1.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 5478/04
Applicant National Trust and Investment Co. Ltd. Lodged
Decided
14-02-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N211360 Planning Appeal
Development 3 no. 1 bed apartments and associated works.

157 Capel Street, Dublin 1.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant National Trust & Investment Co. Ltd. Lodged
Decided
18-03-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N211692 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing buildings, construct 330 residential units in 6 no. apartment blocks varying in height from 3 storey to 7 storey
parking, creche and all associated site works.
Shanowen Business Park, Shanowen Road, Santry, Dublin 9.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 6058/04
Applicant Heritage Properties Ltd Lodged
Decided
08-04-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N212246 Planning Appeal
Development Bay window to front, 1st floor extension to side/front over existing single storey structure, single storey extension to rear
and attic conversion.
4 Sion Hill Road, Drumcondra, Dublin 9.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1677/05
Applicant Paul & Linda Keegan, Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N212257 Planning Appeal
Development 3 dwellings

301 Casement Road, Finglas West, Dublin 11.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1927/05
Applicant Heles Zaky, Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N212442 Planning Appeal
Development End of terrace house and vehicular access.

1 Greencastle Drive, Coolock, Dublin 17.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1903/05
Applicant James Browne Lodged
Decided
31-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N213935 Planning Appeal
Development Removal of existing single storey extension to rear and construction of 2 storey extension.

127 Jamestown Road, Finglas, Dublin 11.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 3596/05
Applicant Tom Kavanagh Lodged
Decided
02-09-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Application withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 29S209565 Planning Appeal
Development Mixed use development comprising a new viewing stand, 111 no. apartments, a creche, parking, ticket sales kiosk, clubhouse,
gymnasium, offices and associated works including riverside walk.
Leinster Branch IRFU, Donnybrook Road, Dublin 4.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 5890/03
Applicant Leinster Branch I.R.F.U, Lodged
Decided
05-11-2004
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211619 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of increase in height of roofline with subsequent increase in height of three chimneys, rooflight and increase in
floor area of attic rooms.
80 Grosvenor Lane, Rathmines, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1152/04
Applicant Tony and Teresa O'Dea Lodged
Decided
30-03-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S212230 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of vehicular and pedestrian gates into the development known as Kilmainham Bank as approved under reg.ref.No. 3836/01.

155-117a Emmet Road, Inchicore, Dublin 8.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1652/05
Applicant APT Development Limited Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S212231 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish storehouse at 2 Pim Street, part demolish structure at 2 Newport Street and erect 5 apartments on site, laundry, stores, 8
balconies and 2 roof gardens.
2 Pim Street/2 Newport Street, Dublin 8.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 5642/04
Applicant Vincent Carey Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S212232 Planning Appeal
Development Retain 3 walls on ground floor with window,door opening off existing extension,3 roof lights,vehicular access with gates, dish
path.Erect trauslucent fibreglass safety sloped roof on existing
walls,porch,1st floor window to front. 53 Cooley Rd,Drimnagh,D12.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1667/05
Applicant Stephen Sinnott Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S212330 Planning Appeal
Development Construction of a 2-storey mews including the demolition of existing mews house, associated site works and landscaping.

Rear of 17 Wellington Place, Dublin 4. (Protected Structure)
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1747/05
Applicant Mr and Mrs S. Fitzpatrick Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 34 212264 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of first floor rear extension with rear balcony, The extension will be a smoker's area attached to
existing public house.
The Shack, Dublin Road, Athlone, Co. Westmeath.
Category
Planning Authority Athlone Town Council, Reg. Ref. 05/3033
Applicant Richard Claffey Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 44 212245 Planning Appeal
Development 4 houses.

Kilmoleran, Waterford Road, Carrick-on-Suir, Co. Tipperary
Category
Planning Authority Carrick-on-suir Town Council, Reg. Ref. PD05/8
Applicant Mastercraft Homes Limited Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 52 RL2241 Referral
Development Change of use of a shop sub-division of Bank of Ireland premises into 2 units at 77-78 O'Connell Street, Clonmel, is or is not
development or is or is not exempted development.
77-78 O'Connell Street, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Clonmel Town Council, Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Dermot Dougan & Patrick Crowley, Lodged
Decided
18-04-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Split decision (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 61 212307 Planning Appeal
Development Change of house type including revised finished floor levels and site layout (Previously granted 03/516).

18, 19, 20, 21 Driseog, Clybaun Road, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 05/132
Applicant Des Kavanagh Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 61 212311 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of parking area to the front with permanent fixed gate/railing.

Curragrean, Doughiska, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 05/126
Applicant Noel Larkin Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 61 214230 Planning Appeal
Development Residential development of 159 units comprising houses and apartments, creche, parking and modifications/improvement to 150m
of Western Distributor Road.
Ballymoneen West, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 05/113
Applicant O'Malley Construction Ltd. Lodged
Decided
22-09-2005
22-09-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 65 212212 Planning Appeal
Development House at rear of existing house using existing site entrance, provide new pedestrian entrance to proposed house and new site
entrance to existing house and associated site works.
Featherbed Lane, Sleveen, Kinsale, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Kinsale Town Council Reg. Ref. 53005/05
Applicant Ken and Cathy O' Brien Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 65 212214 Planning Appeal
Development 64 apartments, 128 parking spaces, refuse bin store/waste recycle compounds, demolition of agricultural structures and access
provisions off Winter's Hill and associated site works.
South of Winter's Hill, Adjacent to Compass Hill, Kinsale, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Kinsale Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/53004
Applicant E & T Builders Limited Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 66 211572 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing house and to construct 6no. apartments for older people, new site entrance, connection to public sewer and
all associated external works.
Carnamuggagh Lower, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Letterkenny Town Council Reg. Ref. L130/04
Applicant William Blunnie Lodged
Decided
30-03-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 66 212201 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations to previously approved reference L144/04 and change of use from domestic dwelling to consultancy rooms and permission
for repositioning of front entrance and works.
Ballyraine Road, Ballyraine, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Letterkenny Town Council Reg. Ref. L19/05
Applicant Edward and Kate Aboud Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 66 213432 Planning Appeal
Development Alterations to existing elevations at units 6,7 and 8.

Letterkenny Shopping Centre, Letterkenny, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Letterkenny Town Council Reg. Ref. L71/05
Applicant Lindat Limited Lodged
Decided
04-08-2005
19-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 68 212355 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of extension, re-open built up door to the front facade of the existing dwelling house, to subdivide into
2 units.
6 & 7 St. Joseph's Road a.k.a Convent Road, Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford Town Council Reg. Ref. 04/69
Applicant James Conboy Lodged
Decided
26-05-2005
21-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 70 213910 Planning Appeal
Development Supermarket and storage area with loading dock, ancillary offices,staff facilities, 4 no. retail units, new carpark with modified
site entrance.
Bellevue, Mallow, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Mallow Town Council Reg. Ref. PD55/031/05
Applicant Dan O'Mahony Lodged
Decided
02-09-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 72 213993 Planning Appeal
Development 60 houses, 28 apartments and creche.

Latlurcan, Old Armagh Road, Co. Monaghan.
Category
Planning Authority Monaghan Town Council Reg. Ref. MT 86/04
Applicant W.J. Dolan Lodged
Decided
07-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 80 214240 Planning Appeal
Development Change 1st floor from residential to restaurant, continue retail use of ground floor as shopping mall. Change use of existing
shopfront, 3-storey extension to
52/53 Main Street, Tipperary Town, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Tipperary Town Council Reg. Ref. PD2/1631
Applicant Kickham Developments Lodged
Decided
20-09-2005
20-09-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 81 211774 Planning Appeal
Development Change site boundaries and change position on site of 2 storey dwelling on site no. 28; permission for open shed to rear.
Site 28 (to be known as 11 Gleann Scotia),
Ballyard, Tralee, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Tralee Town Council Reg. Ref. 6929/5/05
Applicant Euroman Construction Ltd. Lodged
Decided
13-04-2005
23-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 82 210141 Planning Appeal
Development Retention and completion of alterations to previously permitted development (reg.ref 98/4),permission for extension, provision of
new shop front at Castle St., & provision of new shop from Market
St. Market st. and Castle St., Trim, Co.Meath
Category
Planning Authority Trim Town Council Reg. Ref. TT/40013
Applicant Gerry Brady Lodged
Decided
21-12-2004
22-09-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction

End of Report. 116 Case(s)

28-Sep-2005 14:27

Last modified: 2007-03-22

Weekly lists
Planning Appeals
Other cases

All Planning Cases