An Bord Pleanála

Decided cases. Week ended: 21st October 2005. Total cases: 109

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Board Ref. 02 212241 Planning Appeal
Development 10 no. townhouses and 17 no. holiday homes and associated site works.

Darkley, Shercock, Co. Cavan.
Category
Planning Authority Cavan County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/190
Applicant Michael McShane and Paul Scully Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 02 212244 Planning Appeal
Development 4 no. apartments, extend Bed and Breakfast, car parking and associated site works.

Scrabby (Tullyhunco By), Lough Gowna, Co. Cavan.
Category
Planning Authority Cavan County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2602
Applicant Timmy Fitzpatrick Lodged
Decided
18-05-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 212772 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use of hotel to apartments and 3 retail units and extention to bar ect.

Shannon Court Hotel, Ballycasey More, Shannon, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council, Reg. Ref. P04/2177
Applicant Curraha Ltd. Lodged
Decided
21-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 212875 Planning Appeal
Development House, install an effluent treatment system and percolation area and associated site works.

Cloontra, Truagh, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council Reg. Ref. P04/2625
Applicant Alan Mulryne Lodged
Decided
28-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 03 213165 Planning Appeal
Development House, installation of effluent treatment plant and percolation area.

Teeroneer, Bodyke, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Clare County Council Reg. Ref. P05/44
Applicant Michael McNamara Lodged
Decided
13-07-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 04 212325 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of house and construction of new house.

Knocknagore, Crosshaven, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/7511
Applicant James Ryan & Valerie Harness Lodged
Decided
17-05-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212368 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Site No.1, Ard Chuain, Marmullane, Passage West, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/1337
Applicant Ken and Katherine Murphy Lodged
Decided
24-05-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212652 Planning Appeal
Development Construct 2 no.one bedroom apartments, 2 no. two bedroom apartments and 1 no. three bedroom detached house

Barrack Place, Creggane, Buttevant, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/8787
Applicant Simon McAuliffe Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212723 Planning Appeal
Development House and water treatment unit.

Gortdonaghmore, Vicarstown, Blarney, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/1692
Applicant Blarney Fine Foods Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 212725 Planning Appeal
Development House and garage.

Ballyandrew, Doneraile, Co.Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/9608
Applicant Gavin O'Keeffe Lodged
Decided
17-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 04 214565 Planning Appeal
Development 66 no. houses with garages for 9 no. houses, 6 no. apartments, 2 new entrances, ESB sub-station, pumping station and associated
site works.
Ballea Road, Carrigaline West, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3089
Applicant Backline Properties Ltd. Lodged
Decided
17-10-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 04 214594 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition and construction of house.

Ilane, Kealkil, Borlin, Bantry, Co. Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 05/5346
Applicant Tom and Mary O'Sullivan. Lodged
Decided
17-10-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 04 214621 Planning Appeal
Development 66 no. houses with garages for 9 no. houses, 6 no. apartments, 2 new entrances, ESB sub-station, pumping station and associated
site works.
Ballea Road, Carrigaline West, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3089
Applicant Blackline Properties Ltd. Lodged
Decided
19-10-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 04 214622 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of house and construction of 2 no. commercial/retail units and 3 no. apartments.

9 Strand Street, Beach Road, Maulbaun, Passage West, Cork.
Category
Planning Authority Cork County Council Reg. Ref. 04/7225
Applicant Sean Halpin. Lodged
Decided
18-10-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 05 212499 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of a dwelling house, garage and septic tank

Ardgillew, Ballyshannon, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/109
Applicant Agnes McCaffrey Lodged
Decided
03-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05 212656 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of building, construction of 11 apartments, associated site works, car parking

Upper Main Street, Donegal Town, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/345
Applicant Stylo Estates Ltd Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05 212667 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of a terrace of 6 no. 2 storey detached houses, 6 no. 2 storey detached houses and 4 no. 2 storey semi-detached houses and
associated site works.
Drumatumpher and Ballybroll, Frosses, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/100
Applicant Dan Kelly Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05A212607 Planning Appeal
Development Erection of a 12 metre high telecommunications support structure, carrying antennae, link dishes plus associated containerised
equipment, enclosed in a stock-proof fencing
Fallask Upper, Buncrana, Lifford, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/4458
Applicant 02 Communications (Ireland) Limited Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05A212752 Planning Appeal
Development House with septic tank and well

Meenagory, Buncrana, Lifford, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/4430
Applicant Peter Horsnell Lodged
Decided
22-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05B212718 Planning Appeal
Development House with access road and foul sewer mechanical treatment plant

Lackagh, Portnoo, Co. Donegal
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/2174
Applicant Liam Clancy Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05FLA0053 Air Pollution Licence
Development Air Pollution license for the operation of a bitumen/roadstone coating plant.

Ballymagroarty, Ballintra, Co. Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council Laboratory, Reg. Ref. 05/01
Applicant P.McCaffery and Sons Limited. Lodged
Decided
20-04-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse appeal EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 05FWW0298 Water Pollution Licence - Waters
Development License to discharge effluent to waters.

Ballymagroarty, Ballintra, Co.Donegal.
Category
Planning Authority Donegal County Council Laboratory, Reg. Ref. LWAT41
Applicant P.McCaffery and Sons Limited Lodged
Decided
20-04-2005
18-10-2005
Decision [KE +1/64] EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D212403 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of new two storey3 bedroom dwelling and associated site works.

19 Dun Emer Park, Dundrum, Dublin 14
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. DO5A/0324
Applicant B Keaveney Lodged
Decided
30-05-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D212683 Planning Appeal
Development (A)retention of attic conversion and velux roof light, (B)2 no. dormer windows to front and (C)1 no. dormer window to
rear.
7 Sycamore Cresent, Mount Merrion, Co.Dublin
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05B/0219
Applicant Tony Lambe Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D212694 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of an existing two-storey extension on the north side of Aravon Stables and replace it with a three-storey residential
extension.
Aravon Stables, Old Conna, Ferndale Rd.,Rathmichael, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D04A/1454
Applicant Anne and David Coleman Lodged
Decided
17-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06D214288 Planning Appeal
Development 2 houses.

Side of 10 Whyatville Park, Loughlinstown, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0882
Applicant S and P Kearns Lodged
Decided
28-09-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 06D214516 Planning Appeal
Development Two Storey, 5 bedroom dwelling with single storey swimming pool, located to east of existing dwelling (PROTECTED STRUCTURE).
St.George's, St.George's Ave., Killiney Hill Rd., Killiney,
Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci Reg. Ref. D05A/0953
Applicant Jane McQuillan Lodged
Decided
10-10-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Application withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 06F214641 Planning Appeal
Development 31 Houses.
Fieldstown Road, Opposite Shamrock Park,Oldtown,Co.Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council Reg. Ref. FO5A/0389
Applicant P.Collins Lodged
Decided
19-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 06FFS0266 Fire Safety Certificate
Development Design modification to the fit-out of unit 187 (Ecco - shoes).

Blanchardstown Centre, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15.
Category
Planning Authority Fingal County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/4176
Applicant Lodged
Decided
24-06-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Refuse appeal attach conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S212030 Planning Appeal
Development Construct 25m monopole carrying 3 no. 1.7 metre antennae and 3 no.0.3 radio link dishes with associated equipment cabinet & fencing.

Thomas Davis G.A.A., Kiltipper Road, Tallaght, Dublin 24.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. SD04A/0663
Applicant Hutchison 3G Ireland Limited. Lodged
Decided
03-05-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 06S214655 Planning Appeal
Development Removal of garage door and replacing with window and door, new room to be residential.

30 Greenogue Drive, Rathcoole, Co. Dublin.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council Reg. Ref. SD05B/0539
Applicant Noel Tinkler Lodged
Decided
20-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 06S214670 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from hairdressers to take-away.

Simply Elegant, Unit 2 and 3, Scope House, Whitehall Rd, Dublin 24
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council Reg. Ref. SD05A/0631
Applicant Michael Shortt. Lodged
Decided
18-10-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 06SRL2257 Referral
Development Whether erection of antenna support structure in place of existingantenna support structure is or is not development or is or is not
exempted development.
Landy's Industrial Park, Knocklyon road, Dublin 16.
Category
Planning Authority South Dublin County Council, Reg. Ref. ED05/003
Applicant Hutchinson 3G Ireland Ltd. Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Is development and is not exempted development EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 07 212747 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of external shuttering on Spar retail units 1-4.

Townland of Cahergowan, Claregalway, Co. Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/1203
Applicant Sean Dunleavy Lodged
Decided
21-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Report(2)
Board Ref. 08 210574 Planning Appeal
Development 71 hotel suites, 8 apartment hotel units, bar, restaurant, retail space, conference areas and associated infrastructure car parking
(75 spaces) and landscaping at site of former Castle Hotel.
Ozone Terrace, Ballybunion, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 2540/03
Applicant Ballybunion Beach Hotel Ltd. Lodged
Decided
26-01-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Order
Board Ref. 08 212630 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of existing service road.

Mountoven, Camp, Tralee, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/3397
Applicant Ray and Mary O'Mahony Lodged
Decided
14-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212664 Planning Appeal
Development Studio and garage/shed.

Killaha West, Kenmare, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/4561
Applicant Clare & Peter Zoeller Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212711 Planning Appeal
Development Flagpole sign.

Caherweesheen, Tralee, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 885/05
Applicant Lidl Ireland Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212712 Planning Appeal
Development Balcony and ancillary works.

Murreigh, Waterville, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 918/05
Applicant Gerry and Anne Ormond Lodged
Decided
17-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Grant permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 212733 Planning Appeal
Development Retain and complete dwelling and associated site works, permission to install septic tank puraflo wastewater treatment
system and sand polishing filter.
Killegy Lower, Muckross, Killarney, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council, Reg. Ref. 2368/04
Applicant Martin Huggard Lodged
Decided
21-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 08 214653 Planning Appeal
Development Retain & Complete existing dwelling.

Portmagee, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council Reg. Ref. 2620/05
Applicant David & Monica Hussey Lodged
Decided
17-10-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 08 214654 Planning Appeal
Development Retain existing workshop.

Cullenagh Lower, Beaufort, Killarney, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Kerry County Council Reg. Ref. 05\2535
Applicant Eamonn O'Sullivan. Lodged
Decided
21-10-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Invalid- no grounds S.127(1)(d) EIS No
Board Ref. 09 212234 Planning Appeal
Development Single storey extension to side of house, new side wall.

132 & 132A Wogansfield, Leixlip, Co. Kildare.
Category
Planning Authority Kildare County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2575
Applicant Derek Blaney Lodged
Decided
16-05-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 10 212475 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to hotel and leisure centre to include 160 bedrooms, bar, restaurantetc., new 61 bed nursing home, 107 numbered
apartments in four blocks, parking, access and ancillary works.
McEniff Ard Ri Hotel, Mount Misery, Kilculliheen, County Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council Reg. Ref. 04/1902
Applicant View Forth Ltd Lodged
Decided
02-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 10 212696 Planning Appeal
Development 57 no. houses, 9 service sites, site entrance and all associated siteworks.

Harristown, Graiguenamanagh, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1823
Applicant Jack Lennon Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 10 212698 Planning Appeal
Development Deepening of an existing limestone quarry, weighbridge and weighbridge office.

Powerstown East, Goresbridge, Co. Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/473
Applicant Kilcarrig Quarries Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 12 212700 Planning Appeal
Development House, effluent treatment system, access, connection to existing service and all associated works.

Leamanish Td., Feagh, Co.Leitrim.
Category
Planning Authority Leitrim County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/969
Applicant Gerry Courtney Lodged
Decided
17-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 212640 Planning Appeal
Development House with shed for workshop and storage and associated works.

Morenane, Askeaton, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2642
Applicant John Sheehy, Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 212648 Planning Appeal
Development 6 no. houses, extension to access road and associated works.

Bank Place, Hospital, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2891
Applicant Michael O'Sullivan, Lodged
Decided
14-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 13 214563 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish house and construct 10 no. houses, 3 no. apartments and associated works.

Gortboy, Newcastle West, Co. Limerick.
Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council Reg. Ref. 04/3720
Applicant Beverly McGowan Lodged
Decided
14-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 13 214583 Planning Appeal
Development Renovate dwelling with new extension to rear. "Orana", Castlemungret, Co. Limerick.

Category
Planning Authority Limerick County Council Reg. Ref. 04/3326
Applicant Lodged
Decided
14-10-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 14 212742 Planning Appeal
Development Ten houses with associated services and site works.

Kilbride, Abbeylara, Co.Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/728
Applicant Liam McKeogh Lodged
Decided
21-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 15 211575 Planning Appeal
Development Dwelling house, wastewater treatment unit and percolation area.

Funshog, Collon, Co. Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1411
Applicant Shane Carberry Lodged
Decided
29-03-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 211576 Planning Appeal
Development Dwellinghouse, wastewater treatment unit and percolation area.

Funshog, Collon, Co. Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1410
Applicant Padraig Carberry Lodged
Decided
29-03-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse outline permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 212605 Planning Appeal
Development A 24m high lattice tower with antennae and link dishes, vodafone equipment container and all surrounded by a 2.5 high channel
fencing and site works.
Philipstown, Tallanstown, Dundalk, Co. Louth
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1242
Applicant Vodafone Ireland Limited Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 15 212606 Planning Appeal
Development An agriculture entrance to lands from public road

Old Road, Bellurgan, Co. Louth
Category
Planning Authority Louth County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/277
Applicant Thomas Murphy Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 16 214617 Planning Appeal
Development Installation of air handling unit to rear of existing storage/shed along with ancillary site works.

Main Street, Lowpark, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Mayo County Council Reg. Ref. 05/173
Applicant John Healy Lodged
Decided
17-10-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 17 211498 Planning Appeal
Development 75 units houses/apartments, alternative ground floor layout to house type C, creche, associated site works, access roads,
car parking, underground water attenuation.
Blackcastle Demense, Navan, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. NA/40564
Applicant Eamonn Hopkins Lodged
Decided
24-03-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 212777 Planning Appeal
Development House, detached garage, entrance gaters septic tank and associatedsite works.

Leonardstown Mullagh Cross, Summerhill, Co.Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council, Reg. Ref. DA/050119
Applicant Fred Murrey Lodged
Decided
28-06-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 17 213920 Planning Appeal
Development 9 no. residential units and 1 no. child minding facility.

Eastham Road, Bettystown, Co. Meath.
Category
Planning Authority Meath County Council Reg. Ref. SA/50125
Applicant The Swallow Property Lodged
Decided
05-09-2005
17-10-2005
Decision No Board jurisdiction EIS No
Board Ref. 19 213720 Planning Appeal
Development 266 dwellings, new link road, effluent pumping station.

Clonmullen, Edenderry, co.offaly.
Category
Planning Authority Offaly County Council Reg. Ref. PL2/04/1558
Applicant Chatsworth Construction Lodged
Decided
23-08-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 19AFS0261 Fire Safety Certificate
Development Proposed mall incorporating 5 retail units, 3 offices toilet facilities, 2 entrances, one to rear.

Queen Street, Main Street, Banagher, Co. Offaly.
Category
Planning Authority Offaly County Council, Reg. Ref. FS/240093
Applicant Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Allow appeal amend conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 20 212679 Planning Appeal
Development 51 houses and ancillary site works.

Demerne Townland, Ballindrimley, Castlerea, Co. Roscommon.
Category
Planning Authority Roscommon County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/2367
Applicant Newell Construction Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 22 212637 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to existing mine and construction of 3 ventilation shafts.

Ballyerk, Derriville and Killoran, Moyne, Thurles, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 04511667
Applicant Anglo American Lisheen Mining Ltd. Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 22 212773 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Parkmore, Roscrea, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority North Tipperary County Council, Reg. Ref. 055 10399
Applicant Jerry and Maureen Cahir Lodged
Decided
22-06-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 24 212090 Planning Appeal
Development Single storey house with associated service and site works.

Knockatouk, Ballyduff Upper, Co. Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1754
Applicant Helen Walsh Lodged
Decided
03-05-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 24 212312 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of buildings, new storage building and greenhouse, new boundary treatment, petrol interceptor and associated site
works.
Cloncoskeran, Dungarvan, Co. Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/96
Applicant Michael Keane Lodged
Decided
20-05-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 26 212604 Planning Appeal
Development Revised layout around East terrace, incorporating two turnstile blocks and all associated site works.

Townparks, Wexford Rural, Co.Wexford
Category
Planning Authority Wexford County Council, Reg. Ref. 2005/0669
Applicant Wexford County Board G.A.A Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 211909 Planning Appeal
Development Mixed town centre development including 40 no. apartments and 28 no. car parking spaces.

Season Park, Newtownmountkennedy, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/146
Applicant Swan Oak Limited, Lodged
Decided
20-04-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 211999 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to house.

7, Bayside Glen, Dunbar Road, Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/1765
Applicant Adrian Miller Lodged
Decided
28-04-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 212017 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of mobile home, shed, ect for 18 months.

Aughavannah, Revell, Aughrim, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/2378
Applicant Peadar O'Tuathail Lodged
Decided
27-04-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 212645 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of extension to house and permission to demolish shed and install a mechanical aerated treatment plant.

Ballyknockan, Valleymount, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 04/201
Applicant Colin Walsh, Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 212647 Planning Appeal
Development House.

Ballydonarea, Sea Road, Kilcoole, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/2582
Applicant Thomas Horan, Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant outline permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 212653 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of front porch and extensions and conversion of outhouses to apartment.

Toberbeg, Dunlavin, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council, Reg. Ref. 05/2600
Applicant Timothy and Mary Corcoran. Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 27 214448 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish sheds and construct 3 no. dwellings. Riverdale, Lower Street, Aughrim, Co. Wicklow.

Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3106
Applicant Kevin Mann and Pat Canavan Lodged
Decided
04-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- late S.127(1)(g) EIS No
Board Ref. 27 214578 Planning Appeal
Development House and associated works. Ballard, Shillelagh, Co. Wicklow.

Category
Planning Authority Wicklow County Council Reg. Ref. 05/3530
Applicant Lodged
Decided
17-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- lodged outside office hours S.127(5)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 28 211115 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish house 'Grianbru' and former post office, erect mixed use development of 22 no. apartments, cafe, retail unit, carparking,
all associated site works.
Model Farm Rd, Victoria Cross Rd, Dennehy's Cross, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 04/29091
Applicant Richard Walsh and Dick Kiely Lodged
Decided
07-03-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 28 212657 Planning Appeal
Development Two storey extension and new window on rear elevation

Doirin Aluinn, Curraheen Road, Bishopstown, Cork
Category
Planning Authority Cork City Council Reg. Ref. 05/29508
Applicant Denis Ryan Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
19-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N212371 Planning Appeal
Development Residential development to include 135 no. dwellings in 11 blocks and all associated site works.

Sillogue Road, Ballymun, Dublin 11.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1837/05
Applicant Ballymun Regeneration Ltd. Lodged
Decided
24-05-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS Yes
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 29N212564 Planning Appeal
Development Conversion of house to 4 no. apartments alteration to road entrance and driveway, demolition of outbuildings and all
associated works.
Tudor House, Oulton Road, Kincora Park, Clontarf, Dublin 3.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1007/05
Applicant Gerard Gannon Lodged
Decided
09-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
View the Direction(2)
Board Ref. 29N212665 Planning Appeal
Development New signage and alterations to shop front.

SPAR, 365-367 North Circular Road, Phibsboro, Dublin 7.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 2195/05
Applicant Harrisvale Ltd Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N212671 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of outbuildings; construction of 3 storey building to contain 12 no. apartments; alterations to driveway and road
entrance, car parking and associated works.
Tudor House, Oultan Road, Kincora Park, Clontarf, Dublin 3.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council, Reg. Ref. 1100/05
Applicant Gerard Gannon Lodged
Decided
14-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29N214697 Planning Appeal
Development 2 no. houses with vehicular entrance and all associated works.

84 and 85 Aulden Grange, Santry, Dublin 9.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 4074/05
Applicant Mr & Mrs, K Bonnie and P Feeney Lodged
Decided
20-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- fee S.127(1)(f) EIS No
Board Ref. 29S211411 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of existing premises and construction of a 5 storey building consisting of 2 no.retail units, 13 no.apartments, an
office building and associated works.
101-103 Francis street, Dublin 8.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 6088/04
Applicant Thomas Kennedy Lodged
Decided
22-03-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 29S211865 Planning Appeal
Development Mixed use development to include 101 apartments, office building, 3 ground floor units, ESB substation, switchroom, plant rooms and
demolition of existing buildings.
35-39 Usher's Quay and 3-10 Usher Street, Dublin 8.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 5654/04
Applicant P.Elliot and Company Ltd. Lodged
Decided
20-04-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S211929 Planning Appeal
Development Completion and retention of partially constructed first floor extension.

49 Railway Avenue, Inchicore, Dublin 8.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 1536/05
Applicant Thomas Horan Lodged
Decided
26-04-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S212682 Planning Appeal
Development Demolition of house, construction of 21no. residential units in two blocks to include 13no. apartments and 8no. houses, parking
and ancillary works.
59 Orwell Park, Rathgar, Dublin 6.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 2121/05
Applicant Brian M Durkan and Co. Ltd. Lodged
Decided
13-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S212775 Planning Appeal
Development House with access via laneway from Charlemont Road.

Rear of 120 Tritonville Road,Sandymount, Dublin 4.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 5396/04
Applicant Kieran and Ashleen Mulligan Lodged
Decided
21-06-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 29S213948 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish existing bungalow, garage and outbuilding. construct 3 no. two storey dwellings, 6 car parking spaces and all
associated site works.
6 Golden bridge Walk, Inchicore, Dublin 8.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. 3355/05
Applicant Damien and Alison Maddock. Lodged
Decided
05-09-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 29SFS0263 Fire Safety Certificate
Development Proposed fourth floor extension comprising roof terrace bar over bar and restaurants.

Odessa, 13-14 Dame Court, Dublin 2.
Category
Planning Authority Dublin City Council Reg. Ref. FA/05/1118
Applicant Odessa Ltd Lodged
Decided
01-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Refuse appeal EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 30 214439 Planning Appeal
Development Change of use from auto repair unit to funeral home. New Road, Pennywell, Limerick.

Category
Planning Authority Limerick City Council Reg. Ref. 05/325
Applicant Lodged
Decided
06-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- name/address S.127(1)(b) EIS No
Board Ref. 31 212621 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to hotel and leisure centre to include 160 bedrooms, bar, restaurant etc., new 61 bed nursing home, 107 numbered
apartments in four blocks, parking, access and ancillary works.
McEniff Ard Rí Hotel, Ferrybank, Waterford.
Category
Planning Authority Waterford City Council, Reg. Ref. 04/551
Applicant Viewforth Ltd. Lodged
Decided
09-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 33 214442 Planning Appeal
Development Waste recycling facility. Croghan Industrial Estate, Cemetary Road, Arklow, Co. Wicklow.

Category
Planning Authority Arklow Town Council Reg. Ref. 65/2005
Applicant Leon Transport and Recycling Company Lodged
Decided
06-10-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e EIS No
Board Ref. 39 212077 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to house.

5 King Edward Road, Bray, Co. Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Bray Town Council, Reg. Ref. 05/26
Applicant Carol O' Farrell, Lodged
Decided
03-05-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 46 212734 Planning Appeal
Development Retention of shed and change of use to créche.

88, McHale Road, Castlebar, Co. Mayo.
Category
Planning Authority Castlebar Town Council, Reg. Ref. PD3293
Applicant Connie Cannon Lodged
Decided
17-06-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions (Split Decision - See Board order) EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 52 214159 Planning Appeal
Development Demolish houses, offices,workshop, builders yard and develop ground level car park.

Cashel Street and William Street, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary.
Category
Planning Authority Clonmel Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/38
Applicant Thomas Morris Lodged
Decided
16-09-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Application withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 54 DT2034 Determination
Development Determination of the contribution required under condition number 4 of PL54.127685, change of use from dwellinghouse to
restaruant.
7 Dublin Road, Drogheda, Co.Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Drogheda Town Council Reg. Ref. 01/108
Applicant Arclan Properties Lodged
Decided
17-10-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Invalid-fee EIS No
Board Ref. 54 RL2256 Referral
Development Whether the antennae attached to the Hallmark Building is or is not development or is or is not exempt development.

2 West Street, Drogheda, Co. Louth.
Category
Planning Authority Drogheda Town Council Reg. Ref.  
Applicant Vodafone Ireland Ltd Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Is development and is not exempted development EIS No
View the Report View the Order
Board Ref. 58 211183 Planning Appeal
Development Drive-thru restaurant, ancillary signage and car-parking.

Lifford, Gort Road, Ennis, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Ennis Town Council Reg. Ref. 03/194
Applicant McDonalds Restaurant of Ireland Ltd, Lodged
Decided
08-03-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 58 213876 Planning Appeal
Development Internally illuminated double sided turn pole sign.
Aldi Store, Francis Street, Ennis, Co. Clare.
Category
Planning Authority Ennis Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/86
Applicant Aldi Stores (Ireland) Ltd. Lodged
Decided
29-08-2005
21-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 61 212703 Planning Appeal
Development Alteration and extension to existing dwelling and change of use toresidential care facility for use by Galway Simon Community.

41 Fr. Griffin Road, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 04/968
Applicant Galway Simon Community Lodged
Decided
15-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 61 213604 Planning Appeal
Development 8 no. five bed detached houses with garages, new vehicular site access including access road and all associated site works.
Junction of Doughiska Road and Oranmore Coast Road,
Roscam, Galway.
Category
Planning Authority Galway City Council Reg. Ref. 04/816
Applicant John and Anne Commins Lodged
Decided
12-08-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 62 212345 Planning Appeal
Development Extensions and alterations to department store.

Winstons, Kieran Street, Kilkenny.
Category
Planning Authority Kilkenny Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/22
Applicant Ftn Limited, Trading As Winstons Lodged
Decided
24-05-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a) EIS No
Board Ref. 63 212798 Planning Appeal
Development 6 no. advertising stands.

Dereen, Killarney, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Killarney Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/4358
Applicant Legion G.A.A Club Lodged
Decided
24-06-2005
20-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 67 212643 Planning Appeal
Development Erect a statue within castle grounds (protected structure).

The Square, Listowel, Co. Kerry.
Category
Planning Authority Listowel Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/4020
Applicant North Kerry Literary Trust Lodged
Decided
14-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 68 212015 Planning Appeal
Development Signage on the east elevation.

St. Joseph's Road and 1 New Street, Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford Town Council Reg. Ref. 05/6
Applicant Frank Regan Lodged
Decided
29-04-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 68 212736 Planning Appeal
Development Two Storey Building comprising 1no. apartment on each floor with associated services and site works at rear.

24 Chapel Lane, Longford.
Category
Planning Authority Longford Town Council Reg. Ref. 04/116
Applicant Pat Faughnan Lodged
Decided
16-06-2005
18-10-2005
Decision Refuse Permission EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 75 CD2042 Compulsory Acq. of Derelict Site
Development Derelict Site at The Shambles, Mary Street, New Ross, County Wexford.

Category Local Authority Project
Planning Authority New Ross Town Council Reg. Ref.  
Applicant New Ross Town Council Lodged
Decided
19-05-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant consent without modification EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction
Board Ref. 86 212739 Planning Appeal
Development Extension to house.

52 Dunbar Park, Wicklow.
Category
Planning Authority Wicklow Town Council Reg. Ref. 2925/05
Applicant Belinda Walsh Lodged
Decided
17-06-2005
17-10-2005
Decision Grant permission with revised conditions EIS No
View the Report View the Order View the Direction

End of Report. 109 Case(s)

26-Oct-2005 17:18

Last modified: 2005-10-26

Weekly lists
Planning Appeals
Other cases

All Planning Cases