An Bord Pleanála

Cases Disposed of. Week ended: 7th May 2010 Total cases: 48

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Jump to: Carlow, Clare, Cork, Donegal, Dublin, Galway, Kerry, Kildare, Laois, Leitrim, Limerick, Louth, Mayo, Meath, Tipperary, Westmeath, Wexford, Wicklow

Carlow

235706: Roscat, Tullow, Co. Carlow. (09/324)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL01 .235706)
  • Description: Two-storey house and associated siteworks.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Carlow County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/324)
  • Date lodged: 05/01/2010; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Anastasia O'Brien and Gerard Rooney

Clare

235856: Hillcrest / Tulla Road, Ennis, Co. Clare. (09/83)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL58 .235856)
  • Description: Outline permission to connect existing house to public sewer, outline permission to demolish existing garage and construct a house the rear of existing house with all associated site works.
  • Decision: Refuse permission
  • Planning Authority: Ennis Town Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/83)
  • Date lodged: 20/01/2010; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Pat Fitzpatrick

234635: Kettle Street, Lahinch, Co. Clare. (09/579)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL03 .234635)
  • Description: Retention of modifications to reg.ref. no. P07/37 comprising change of use of first floor living accommodation to restaurant seating, extension of first floor and provision of fire escape.
  • Decision: Refuse Permission
  • Planning Authority: Clare County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/579)
  • Date lodged: 25/08/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Alan Logue

Cork

RL2688: Ballinclashet, Belgooly, Co. Cork.

  • Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL04 .RL2688)
  • Description: Whether a proposed extension to a cotage is or is not development or is or is not exempted development.
  • Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
  • Planning Authority: Cork County Council, (Reg. Ref.: )
  • Date lodged: 08/12/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Eamonn and Pauline Murphy

235786: 65 Lower O'Connell Street, Kinsale, Co. Cork. (09/53017)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL65 .235786)
  • Description: Construct ground floor apartment with overhead two storey apartment and associated site works.
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Kinsale Town Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/53017)
  • Date lodged: 13/01/2010; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Gerard O'Connor,

235645: Dundanion Lodge, Blackrock Road, Cork. (09/34136)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL28 .235645)
  • Description: Construction of a house with associated site development works.
  • Decision: Application withdrawn S.140(1)(a)
  • Planning Authority: Cork City Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/34136)
  • Date lodged: 21/12/2009; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: John Kelly.

235489: Ballygrogan, Grenagh, Co. Cork. (09/7071)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL04 .235489)
  • Description: Retention of existing palisade fence, earth beams, portacabin for office use and 2 no. metal containers for domestic storage use.
  • Decision: Refuse permission
  • Planning Authority: Cork County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/7071)
  • Date lodged: 04/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Micheal P. Quirke,

235342: Glanturkin, Whitegate, Co. Cork. (09/4289)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL04 .235342)
  • Description: Installation of tri-cel treatment system, sash windows, timber entrance door, lime mortar to all main elevations, retention of slate roof and block work to adjoin external toilet to house.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Cork County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/4289)
  • Date lodged: 16/11/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Tom Kent

Donegal

235628: Dunmore, Carrigans, Co. Donegal. (09/70082)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL05A.235628)
  • Description: 27 houses, 3 no. apartments, 2 no. retail units and connection to existing sewage treatment plant (granted under reg ref: 05/70889) and all associated site works.
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Donegal County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/70082)
  • Date lodged: 17/12/2009; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Paddy Toland.

233422: Carrowmullin, Fahan, Co. Donegal. (08/70622)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL05A.233422)
  • Description: 27 houses, all ancillary site works within the curtilage of Fahan House.(Protected structure).
  • Decision: Refuse outline permission
  • Planning Authority: Donegal County Council (Reg. Ref.: 08/70622)
  • Date lodged: 20/04/2009; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Fermac Properties Limited.

Dublin

RL2717: Unit 2B Stephenstown Industrial Estate, Balbriggan, Co. Dublin. (S5/005/10)

  • Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL06F.RL2717)
  • Description: Whether the use of Unit 2B as a storage facility for impounded cars is or is not development or is or is not exempted development (PA Reg Ref F06A/0057)
  • Decision: Invalid- subject matter not stated S.127(1)(c)
  • Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: S5/005/10)
  • Date lodged: 17/02/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Hoare's Service Station

236695: 28 Luttrellstown Heath, Castleknock, Dublin 15. (FW10A/0028)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06F.236695)
  • Description: Demolition of garage and construction of house to the side of existing house and all associated works.
  • Decision: Invalid- late S.127(1)(g)
  • Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: FW10A/0028)
  • Date lodged: 05/05/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Gerard Barker

236002: 1 Hammond Street, Blackpitts, Dublin 8. (4246/09)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29S.236002)
  • Description: Demolish extension to rear and construct new two storey over extension to side and rear.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 4246/09)
  • Date lodged: 08/02/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Peter and Anne Crotty,

235896: 35 Windmill Road, Dublin 12. (WEB1195/09)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29S.235896)
  • Description: Single storey extension to front.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: WEB1195/09)
  • Date lodged: 25/01/2010; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Linda Brady,

235875: 10 Sweetbriar Lane, Kilmacud, Dublin 14. (D09B/0429)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.235875)
  • Description: Attic conversion and associated works.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D09B/0429)
  • Date lodged: 19/01/2010; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Brian Lynch

235811: 3 Claremont Road, Killiney, Co. Dublin. (D09A/0756)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.235811)
  • Description: Granny flat extension and associated works.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D09A/0756)
  • Date lodged: 13/01/2010; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: John Keane

235684: 24 Butterfield Park, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14. (SD09B/0390)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06S.235684)
  • Description: Retain as built alterations to planning permission SD07B/0902, including changes to front entrance porch, side passage, rear family room, window/doors, velux roof lights, eaves and parapet
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: South Dublin County Council (Reg. Ref.: SD09B/0390)
  • Date lodged: 24/12/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Kevin O'Brien

235680: 77 Foxes Grove, Shankill, Dublin 18. (D09B/0400)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.235680)
  • Description: Alterations and extension to house and associated works.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions (Split Decision - See Board order)
  • Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D09B/0400)
  • Date lodged: 21/12/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Ken Coady

235671: Dunluce, 21 Anglesea Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4. (4049/09)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29S.235671)
  • Description: Demolish building "Dunluce", construct 29 no. apartments and all associated works.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 4049/09)
  • Date lodged: 23/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Tom Bailey

235668: Willsboro Stables, Killeek, St. Margaret's, County Dublin. (F09A/0543)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06F.235668)
  • Description: Construction of a house with new vehicular entrance and all associated site works.
  • Decision: Refuse permission
  • Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: F09A/0543)
  • Date lodged: 23/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Gerard McLeod

235571: 33 Millstead, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. (FW09B/0094)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06F.235571)
  • Description: Retention of structure containing music room,study and shower. Permission for alterations to retained structure, permission for extension and all associated works.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: FW09B/0094)
  • Date lodged: 11/12/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Aidan Tierney,

235472: Waterside, Queenstown Castle, 34 Coliemore Rd, Dalkey, Co. Dublin. (09A/0682)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.235472)
  • Description: House and associated works and completion of boathouse and slipway with access through a protected structure.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: 09A/0682)
  • Date lodged: 01/12/2009; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Tom Kavanagh

Galway

RL2689: 8 Grattan Road, Claddagh, Co. Galway. (PDC3/33/09)

  • Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL61 .RL2689)
  • Description: Whether an additional window to the rear upper floor of a property is or is not exempted development at
  • Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
  • Planning Authority: Galway City Council (Reg. Ref.: PDC3/33/09)
  • Date lodged: 15/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Patrick Curran,

236077: Cloonascragh, Tuam, Co. Galway. (09/1933)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL07 .236077)
  • Description: Retention of existing house.
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Galway County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/1933)
  • Date lodged: 16/02/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Richard Cloonan

235965: Killeenmunterlane North, Kinvara Rd., Kilcolgan, Co. Galway. (09/2068)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL07 .235965)
  • Description: Construct a dormer bungalow, garage septic tank with percolation area and all associated services and alterations to farm entrance.
  • Decision: Refuse Permission
  • Planning Authority: Galway County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/2068)
  • Date lodged: 03/02/2010; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Patricia Donohue

Kerry

LV3055: Tullahennel South, Ballylongford, Co. Kerry. (09/1175)

  • Case Type: Leave to Appeal S37(6) (Board Reference: PL08 .LV3055)
  • Description: Windfarm consisting of 10 wind turbines, control building, access road, electrical substation, anemometer and ancillary works for 10 year period.
  • Decision: Application for leave to appeal refused
  • Planning Authority: Kerry County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/1175)
  • Date lodged: 16/04/2010; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Paddy Madden

LV3050: Tullahennel South, Ballylongford, Co. Kerry. (09/1175)

  • Case Type: Leave to Appeal S37(6) (Board Reference: PL08 .LV3050)
  • Description: Windfarm consisting of 10 wind turbines, control building, access roads, electrical substation, anemometer and ancillary works for 10 year period.
  • Decision: Application for leave to appeal refused
  • Planning Authority: Kerry County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/1175)
  • Date lodged: 13/04/2010; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Paddy Madden

235654: Cable Station, The Old Cable House, Spunkane, Waterville, Co.Kerry (09/348)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL08 .235654)
  • Description: Mixed used development of 5 no. townhouses, one ground floor commercial unit with apartment over, car parking, site works within the curtilage of protected structure.
  • Decision: Refuse Permission
  • Planning Authority: Kerry County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/348)
  • Date lodged: 21/12/2009; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Liam Davis.

Kildare

236059: Derrinturn, Carbury, Co. Kildare. (09/1292)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL09 .236059)
  • Description: Change of use of ground floor retail area to retail area with ancillary off-license use.
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Kildare County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/1292)
  • Date lodged: 15/02/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: K and D Costcutter Limited

235776: County Kildare. (08/2159)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL09 .235776)
  • Description: Continuation of restoration activities at an existing sand and gravel pit. Townlands of Walshestown,Blackhall,Tipperkevin and Bawnogue
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Kildare County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 08/2159)
  • Date lodged: 12/01/2010; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Cemex (ROI) Limited

Laois

235670: Kilnacourt House, Portarlington, Co. Laois. (09/482)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL11 .235670)
  • Description: Re-instatement and extension of the outbuildings at Kilnacourt House which are protected structures to a pharmacy, kiosk and cafeteria and all associated siteworks.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Laois County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/482)
  • Date lodged: 23/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Le-Monde Holdings Ltd

Leitrim

234741: Manorhamilton, Co. Leitrim. (09/260)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL12 .234741)
  • Description: Construct windfarm consisting of eight turbines and all ancillary site works. Killea, Bolleyboy and Lugnasnaghta, Dough Mountain,
  • Decision: Refuse Permission
  • Planning Authority: Leitrim County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/260)
  • Date lodged: 08/09/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: An Dough Windfarm Ltd

Limerick

235715: Main Street, Shanagolden, Co. Limerick. (09/8)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL13 .235715)
  • Description: Demolition of house, store and shed and construct a new house and all associated site works.
  • Decision: Refuse permission
  • Planning Authority: Limerick County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/8)
  • Date lodged: 06/01/2010; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Richard Moloney

Louth

VC0047: No Address

  • Case Type: Electrity Development Consultation (Board Reference: PL15 .VC0047)
  • Description: Proposed connection of Ballakelly CCGT into Louth 275 kV station.
  • Decision: Is not Strat. Infrast. Dev.
  • Planning Authority: Louth County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
  • Date lodged: 19/04/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: EirGrid,

235737: Ardee Business Park, Hale Street, Ardee, Co. Louth. (09/678)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL15 .235737)
  • Description: Industrial/office building comprising of 10 units, site works to include alteration to existing car park, additional car parking spaces and site works.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Louth County Council, (Reg. Ref.: 09/678)
  • Date lodged: 08/01/2010; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Ardee Community Development Co. Limited

Mayo

236686: Magheramore, Bekan, Claremorris, Co. Mayo. (09/664)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL16 .236686)
  • Description: Wind farm consisting of 12 no. wind turbines and anemometry mast, an electrical substation, associated access tracks, underground cabling and works.
  • Decision: Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e
  • Planning Authority: Mayo County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/664)
  • Date lodged: 04/05/2010; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Pwnp Developments Limited

236332: Greenwood, Ballyhaunis, Co. Mayo. (09/941)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL16 .236332)
  • Description: 28 metre high monopole with antenna, transmission dishes and ladder, associated works, equipment cabinet and fencing.
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Mayo County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/941)
  • Date lodged: 22/03/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Hutchison 3G Ireland Limited

236331: Kiltrone, Ballinrobe, Co. Mayo. (09/863)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL16 .236331)
  • Description: 21 metre high monopole with antenna, transmission dishes and ladder, associated works, equipment cabinet, access track and fencing.
  • Decision: Contribution Appeal Decided
  • Planning Authority: Mayo County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/863)
  • Date lodged: 22/03/2010; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Hutchison 3g Ireland Limited

Meath

RL2681: Rathfeigh, Tara, Co. Meath. (NA/S59042)

  • Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL17 .RL2681)
  • Description: Whether three integrated constructed wetland extra ponds (as modified) is or is not development or is or is not exempted development.
  • Decision: Board Decision- see Board Order
  • Planning Authority: Meath County Council (Reg. Ref.: NA/S59042)
  • Date lodged: 06/11/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Michael Fox,

PC0089: No Address

  • Case Type: Private Development S.37B consultations (Board Reference: PL17 .PC0089)
  • Description: Increase In The Rate Of Waste Acceptance, Extension Of The Operational Footprint And New Waste Treatment Infrastructure At Residual Landfill At Knockharley, Co. Meath.
  • Decision: Is a Strat. Infrast. Dev.
  • Planning Authority: Meath County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
  • Date lodged: 15/01/2010; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Greenstar Limited

LV3056: Beshellstown, Clonalvy, co. Meath. (SA901768)

  • Case Type: Leave to Appeal S37(6) (Board Reference: PL17 .LV3056)
  • Description: House, proprietary wastewater treatment system and all associated site works.
  • Decision: Application for leave to appeal refused
  • Planning Authority: Meath County Council (Reg. Ref.: SA901768)
  • Date lodged: 21/04/2010; signed: 04/05/2010
  • Applicant: Mary Clinton

235747: Redbog, Dunshaughlin, Co. Meath. (DA901330)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL17 .235747)
  • Description: Construction of dormer house and all associated siteworks.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Meath County Council (Reg. Ref.: DA901330)
  • Date lodged: 08/01/2010; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Michael O'Brien

Tipperary

235529: Kiltillane, Templemore, Co. Tipperary. (09/530002)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL78 .235529)
  • Description: Construction of a single storey extension to house cremation and incineration equipment for funeral services and associated site works.
  • Decision: Refuse permission
  • Planning Authority: Templemore Town Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/530002)
  • Date lodged: 08/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Eamonn Grey

235432: Ballyglasheen, Kilfeakle, County Tipperary. (09/612)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL23 .235432)
  • Description: Retention of 30 metre birdcage communications structure and additional equipment.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: South Tipperary County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/612)
  • Date lodged: 25/11/2009; signed: 05/05/2010
  • Applicant: Electricity Supply Board

Westmeath

234273: Rhode Road, Beggar's Bridge, Rochfortbridge, Co. Westmeath. (08/4174)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL25 .234273)
  • Description: 30 no. houses and ancillary works. (Orig application for 64 houses)
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Westmeath County Council (Reg. Ref.: 08/4174)
  • Date lodged: 16/07/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: Ardleigh Developments

Wexford

236697: Ballygillane Little, St. Helens, Co. Wexford. (2009/1698)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL26 .236697)
  • Description: Demolition of a house and hotel, construction of a nursing home, access, carparking and all associated site works.
  • Decision: Invalid- no acknowledgement of local submission S.127(1)e
  • Planning Authority: Wexford County Council (Reg. Ref.: 2009/1698)
  • Date lodged: 06/05/2010; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Merchant Properties Limited

235681: Tarahill, Courtown, Co. Wexford. (09/1377)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL26 .235681)
  • Description: Demolish house and erect a split level house.
  • Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
  • Planning Authority: Wexford County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/1377)
  • Date lodged: 23/12/2009; signed: 06/05/2010
  • Applicant: Martin and Leonie Sinnott

Wicklow

235653: 5 Ardbrae Park, Bray, Co. Wicklow. (09/125)

  • Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL39 .235653)
  • Description: Retention of detached dwelling.
  • Decision: Grant permission with conditions
  • Planning Authority: Bray Town Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/125)
  • Date lodged: 22/12/2009; signed: 07/05/2010
  • Applicant: David Rice

Last modified: 07/05/2010

Weekly lists
Planning Appeals
Other cases

All Planning Cases