Cases Disposed of Week Ended: 17-06-2011 Total Cases: 47

In accordance with section 34 of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Board in making decisions on appeals under section 37 of the Act had regard to submissions or observations received.

Jump to: Cavan, Clare, Cork, Dublin, Galway, Kerry, Kildare, Kilkenny, Laois, Limerick, Louth, Mayo, Meath, Roscommon, Tipperary, Wicklow

Cavan

PA0020: Corranure Landfill, Cootehill Road, Cavan, Co. Cavan.

• Case Type: Private Development S.37E application (Board Reference: PL02 .PA0020)
• Description: Integrated Recycling Facility At The Site Of The Existing
• Decision: Application withdrawn
• Planning Authority: Cavan County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
• Date lodged: 24/12/2010; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Oxigen Environmental Limited
• EIS: EIS Produced

Clare

238441: New Quay, Burren, County Clare. (10/744)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL03 .238441)
• Description: House, septic tank, percolation area and all associated site works.
• Decision: Refuse Permission
• Planning Authority: Clare County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/744)
• Date lodged: 15/02/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Anthony Daly
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Cork

238500: Andersons Quay and Oliver Plunkett Street Lower, Cork. (10/34671)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL28 .238500)
• Description: Additional set back floor containing offices of 1,541sqm. on top of six storey retail and office development granted under TP09/34001 and PL28.236004. Site bounded by Clontarf Steet,
• Decision: Refuse Permission
• Planning Authority: Cork City Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/34671)
• Date lodged: 22/02/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Hilltrent Limited
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238427: Site C, Hillsboro, Model Farm Road, Carrigrohane, Co. Cork. (10/8489)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL04 .238427)
• Description: Demolition of flat roofed annex to house, to provide access roadway and construction of a house.
• Decision: Grant outline permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Cork County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/8489)
• Date lodged: 09/02/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: John Lane
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238208: Cloonteens, Lombardstown, Mallow, County Cork. (10/5831)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL04 .238208)
• Description: Construction of a house and associated works.
• Decision: Refuse Permission
• Planning Authority: Cork County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/5831)
• Date lodged: 24/12/2010; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Lorraine and John Rahilly
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

237773: Knockanemore, Ovens, Co. Cork. (10/4769)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL04 .237773)
• Description: Construction of 24 no. houses and all ancillary site development works.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Cork County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/4769)
• Date lodged: 18/10/2010; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: O'Brien and O'Flynn
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

237729: Douglas Hall Mews, Skehard Road, Blackrock, Cork. (10/34392)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL28 .237729)
• Description: Construction of a house and associated site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Cork City Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/34392)
• Date lodged: 06/10/2010; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Alan Gould.
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Dublin

RL2845: 20A Brookhaven Rise, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. (S5W/17/2010)

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL06F.RL2845)
• Description: Whether the construction of boundary wall is development or is not development or is exempted development or is not exempted development.
• Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
• Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: S5W/17/2010)
• Date lodged: 07/02/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Gerard Tuite
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

RL2844: 2 Brookhaven Rise, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. (S5W/16/2010)

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL06F.RL2844)
• Description: Whether the construction of boundary wall at or adjacent to site of a dwelling house is or is not development and is or is not exempted development.
• Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
• Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: S5W/16/2010)
• Date lodged: 07/02/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Ms. Maria Hannigan
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

RL2825: 62 Oak Road, Donnycarney, Dublin 9. (0260/10)

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL29N.RL2825)
• Description: Whether an extension to the rear of an existing dwelling is or is not development or is or is not exempted development.
• Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 0260/10)
• Date lodged: 10/12/2010; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Patricia Gallagher
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

RL2813: Junction of Ravens Rock Rd and Carmanhall Rd,Sandyford Ind.Est, D18. (9410)

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL06D.RL2813)
• Description: Whether a country market to operate occasionally for periods not to exceed in aggregate 30 days in any year is or is not development or is or is not exempted development.
• Decision: Is development and is exempted development
• Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: 9410)
• Date lodged: 17/11/2010; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Irish Village Markets
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

PA0018: Naul, Co. Dublin.

• Case Type: Private Development S.37E application (Board Reference: PL06F.PA0018)
• Description: Integrated waste management facility for the acceptance and landfilling of non-biodegradable inert, non-hazardous and hazardous Waste at Hollywood Great, Nag's Head,
• Decision: Grant consent with modification
• Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
• Date lodged: 10/12/2010; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Murphy Environmental Hollywood Ltd.
• EIS: EIS Produced

LV3108: Units 18and19,Block C,Smithfield Market Development, Smithfield, D7. (4176/10)

• Case Type: Leave to Appeal S37(6) (Board Reference: PL29N.LV3108)
• Description: Amalgamation and change of use of units 18 and 19 permitted under Reg.Ref. No: 4830/06 to provide for single retail unit including signage, subsidary alcohol sales and all ancillary site works.
• Decision: Invalid-fee S.37(6)(a)
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 4176/10)
• Date lodged: 14/06/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Aidan Hora
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

239033: Kimmage Road Lower and Mount Argus Avenue, Harolds Cross, Dublin 6W. (2375/11)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29S.239033)
• Description: Change of use, alterations and extension of former monastery to develop a nursing home, within the curtilage of a protected structure.
• Decision: Appeal declared withdrawn S.140(2)(b)
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 2375/11)
• Date lodged: 30/05/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Vieira Limited
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238727: 7 Ballinteer Avenue, Ballinteer, Dublin 16. (D11A/0023)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.238727)
• Description: Conversion of hip roof to a gable end to incorporate a bedroom with ensuite and dormer window; single-storey extension; internal modifications; new access, ancillary site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions (Split Decision - See Board order)
• Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D11A/0023)
• Date lodged: 04/04/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Deirdre Kennedy
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238607: Lansdowne Lawn Tennis Club, Londonbridge Road, Dublin 4. (4159/10)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29S.238607)
• Description: Alterations and extensions to existing tennis clubhouse.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 4159/10)
• Date lodged: 11/03/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Trustees of Lansdowne Lawn Tennis Club
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238492: Presbytery, Church Avenue, Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. (FW10A/0187)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06F.238492)
• Description: Change of use of former presbytery to funeral home and associated internal and external alterations and all associated landscape, s ite and development works within.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: FW10A/0187)
• Date lodged: 22/02/2011; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Cunninghams Funerals Limited
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238465: Linden Lodge, Castlepark Road, Sandycove, Co. Dublin. (D10A/0674)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.238465)
• Description: Extensions to house and conversion to office use and construction of 5 no. houses and site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D10A/0674)
• Date lodged: 18/02/2011; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Martin Whelan and Richard Murphy
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238450: 2 Landscape Gardens and 31 + 33 Henley Park, Churchtown, Dublin 14 (D10A/0515)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.238450)
• Description: 4 no. houses and site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D10A/0515)
• Date lodged: 15/02/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: William Devitt and Denis Howard
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238443: 2 Doonamana Road, Cabinteely, Dublin 18. (D10A/0640)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.238443)
• Description: House and site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D10A/0640)
• Date lodged: 11/02/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Eunan Byrne
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238422: 15 Charleville Road, Phibsborough, Dublin 7. (3969/10)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29N.238422)
• Description: Covered walkway to the gable side of house and covered external terrace to rear.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 3969/10)
• Date lodged: 09/02/2011; signed: 13/06/2011
• Applicant: Edel O'Connell and Owen Bonner
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238416: 10 Vernon Avenue, Clontarf, Dublin 3. (3978/10)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29N.238416)
• Description: Change of use from residential to ground floor retail unit with office use on ground and first floor.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions (Split Decision - See Board order)
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 3978/10)
• Date lodged: 08/02/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Eoin Kidd
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238413: South Dublin Fiat, Goatstown Road, Goatstown, Dublin 14. (D10A/0623)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06D.238413)
• Description: Refurbishment of existing motor sales premises and change of use to neighbourhood shop with off - licence.
• Decision: Refuse permission
• Planning Authority: Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown County Counci (Reg. Ref.: D10A/0623)
• Date lodged: 08/02/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Jorcon Ltd
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238395: Belinstown, Ballyboughal, County Dublin. (F10A/0275)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06F.238395)
• Description: House.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: F10A/0275)
• Date lodged: 03/02/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Karen Nugent
• EIS: EIS Not Required

237833: Drishoge, Oldtown, Co. Dublin. (F10A/0011)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL06F.237833)
• Description: Demolition of cottage and construction of house.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Fingal County Council (Reg. Ref.: F10A/0011)
• Date lodged: 22/10/2010; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Tracey Walsh
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

237560: 39 Amiens Street/33 Foley Street, Dublin 1. (2383/10)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL29N.237560)
• Description: Change of use from a place of public worship to restaurant at 33 Foley Street, and change of use from commercial retail to takeway at 39 Amiens Street and associated site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Dublin City Council (Reg. Ref.: 2383/10)
• Date lodged: 16/09/2010; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Fintan Phelan,
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Galway

238775: Rinn, Oranmore, Co. Galway. (10/1730)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL07 .238775)
• Description: House, effluent treatment plant and all associated services.
• Decision: Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a)
• Planning Authority: Galway County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/1730)
• Date lodged: 14/04/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: James Furey
• EIS: EIS Not Required

237900: Cregmore, Co. Galway. (10/873)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL07 .237900)
• Description: Sport hall, new polishing filter and percolation area, classroom extension, on site car parking and all associated works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions (Split Decision - See Board order)
• Planning Authority: Galway County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/873)
• Date lodged: 05/11/2010; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Board of Management Cregmore N.S.
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

Kerry

RL2867: Mile High Retail Park, Manor East, Tralee, Co. Kerry. (EX179)

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL08 .RL2867)
• Description: Whether the change of use of a commercial unit (retail warehousing) to convenience retail use is or is not development or is or is not exempted development.
• Decision: Appeal withdrawn S.140(1)(a)
• Planning Authority: Kerry County Council (Reg. Ref.: EX179)
• Date lodged: 03/05/2011; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Anthony and Declan Costello
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

Kildare

238657: Crosskey, Kilbeg, Kildangan, Co. Kildare. (10/1064)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL09 .238657)
• Description: Change of use from shop to sessional/playgroup facility, external play area, revisions to car park layout to rear, revisions to car parking layout within curtilage of adjoining petrol station.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Kildare County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/1064)
• Date lodged: 21/03/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Michael O'Sullivan
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238471: 155 Elton Court, Leixlip, Co. Kildare. (10/782)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL09 .238471)
• Description: Retention of extension to rear of house, extension to garden stores and enclosure of the curtilage of house by a hedge.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Kildare County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/782)
• Date lodged: 18/02/2011; signed: 13/06/2011
• Applicant: Bernard McGinty
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Kilkenny

RL2806: Longwell, Danesfort, County Kilkenny.

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL10 .RL2806)
• Description: Whether the creation of a laneway using hardcore material to access an agricultural shed is or is not development or is or is not exempted development.
• Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
• Planning Authority: Kilkenny County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
• Date lodged: 02/11/2010; signed: 13/06/2011
• Applicant: Michael Shannon
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

Laois

238640: Aghanure Townland, Ballylynan, Co. Laois. (11/15)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL11 .238640)
• Description: Retention of telecommunication monopole carrying antennas and dishes, associated equipment and security fencing.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Laois County Council (Reg. Ref.: 11/15)
• Date lodged: 18/03/2011; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Telefonica 02 Ireland Limited
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238446: Clonadadoran, Portlaoise, Co. Laois. (10/254)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL11 .238446)
• Description: Proposal to revise the location of a concrete yard for shredding of timber and connection to existing class 1 interceptor, previously permitted under Ref: 08/663.
• Decision: Refuse Permission
• Planning Authority: Laois County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/254)
• Date lodged: 15/02/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Bord Na Mona Horticulture Limited.
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238280: No Address (09/782)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL11 .238280)
• Description: Demolish and remove timber frame shell, construction of a nursing home, medical care and childcare facility and all associated works Corrig Glen Manor, Station Road, Portarlington, Co. Laois.
• Decision: Refuse Permission
• Planning Authority: Laois County Council (Reg. Ref.: 09/782)
• Date lodged: 12/01/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Derrycorris Development Group.
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Limerick

238559: Friarstown, Grange, Kilmallock, Co. Limerick. (10/242)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL13 .238559)
• Description: Material change of use from domestic/childminding facility to playschool/afterschool facility, extension and associated works.
• Decision: Refuse Permission
• Planning Authority: Limerick County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/242)
• Date lodged: 04/03/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Mary Cahill,
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Louth

238519: Newtownbalregan, Dundalk, Co. Louth. (10/599)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL15 .238519)
• Description: Outline permission for a house and associated site works.
• Decision: Refuse outline permission
• Planning Authority: Louth County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/599)
• Date lodged: 23/02/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Oliver Tennyson.
• EIS: EIS Not Required

238430: Brownstown, Monasterboice, Drogheda, Co. Louth. (10/570)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL15 .238430)
• Description: Conversion of an existing agricultural building to a house with associated ancillary works.
• Decision: Refuse permission
• Planning Authority: Louth County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/570)
• Date lodged: 10/02/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Bill and Shirley Hoyne
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Mayo

238216: Dooega (Ashleam), Achill, Co. Mayo. (10/906)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL16 .238216)
• Description: Extension to house and associated site works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Mayo County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/906)
• Date lodged: 04/01/2011; signed: 14/06/2011
• Applicant: Martin and Caroline Mangan
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Meath

238665: Navan Railway Station, Railway Street, Navan, Co. Meath. (NT100110)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL32 .238665)
• Description: Alterations to existing gateway, new pavements, fencing, lighting, to provide bus bays for collection of school students and parking of buses. Within curtilage of Protected Structure RPS 157.
• Decision: Grant permission with conditions
• Planning Authority: Navan Town Council (Reg. Ref.: NT100110)
• Date lodged: 23/03/2011; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Bus Eireann.
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Roscommon

RL2847: Carrigeen, Kilglass, Co. Roscommon.

• Case Type: Referral Section 5 (Board Reference: PL20 .RL2847)
• Description: Whether the excavation and creation of a mooring facility is or is not development or is or is not exempted development
• Decision: Is development and is not exempted development
• Planning Authority: Roscommon County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
• Date lodged: 10/02/2011; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: Dara Foynes
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

238501: Ardlougher Townland, Hillstreet, Co. Roscommon. (10/280)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL20 .238501)
• Description: Retention of cattle crush and associated development works.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Roscommon County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/280)
• Date lodged: 24/02/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Brian Keane
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Tipperary

238432: Castletown/Landsdown, Portroe, Nenagh, Tipperary. (10/510342)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL22 .238432)
• Description: Retention of house, garage and entrance as constructed and permission to extend and renovate house and replace wastewater treatment system and percolation area.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: North Tipperary County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/510342)
• Date lodged: 10/02/2011; signed: 16/06/2011
• Applicant: Vera Gould
• EIS: EIS Not Required

Wicklow

RH2042: Cherry Lane, Greystones, Co. Wicklow.

• Case Type: Re Social Housing S96(5) (Board Reference: PL27 .RH2042)
• Description: Determination of the manner in which social and affordable housing obligations of the applicant should be met in accordance with condition no. 10 of PL27.218913.
• Decision: Board Decision- see Board Order
• Planning Authority: Wicklow County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
• Date lodged: 18/03/2010; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: George and Ruth Raymond
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

RH2041: Cherry Lane, Greystones, Co. Wicklow.

• Case Type: Re Social Housing S96(5) (Board Reference: PL27 .RH2041)
• Description: Determination of the manner in which the social and affordable housing obligations of the applicant should be met in accordance with condition 3 of 05/3341.
• Decision: Board Decision- see Board Order
• Planning Authority: Wicklow County Council (Reg. Ref.: )
• Date lodged: 14/12/2009; signed: 15/06/2011
• Applicant: George and Ruth Raymond
• EIS: EIS Not Required.

238426: Beach Road, Greystones, Co. Wicklow. (10/2599)

• Case Type: Planning Appeal (Board Reference: PL27 .238426)
• Description: Modifications and extensions to Duncairn House and Duncairn Mews (protected structure), including a stone and fossil gallery and cafe.
• Decision: Grant permission with revised conditions
• Planning Authority: Wicklow County Council (Reg. Ref.: 10/2599)
• Date lodged: 10/02/2011; signed: 17/06/2011
• Applicant: Seamus Martin
• EIS: EIS Not Required